· Mason Everett · Reviews · 7 min read
10 Best Crumb Tray For Toaster Oven 2026 Reviews
Finding the Best Crumb Tray For Toaster Oven can be a surprisingly difficult task given the wide variety of models and sizes available on the market.
Whether you are looking for a direct replacement part or a universal liner to keep your appliance pristine, evaluating criteria such as material quality, heat resistance, durability, and cleaning ease is essential.
We understand that safety is paramount, so we have prioritized eco-friendly options that are free from harmful chemicals like PFOA and BPA.
Our comprehensive guide is designed to help you make an informed decision by breaking down the top-rated solutions that ensure your cooking experience remains mess-free and enjoyable.
Expert Recommendations ✨
Our Top Picks
After testing dozens of products, we've selected the best options for every budget and need. Each recommendation has been thoroughly evaluated for performance, durability, and value.
Buself Toaster Oven Liner 2 Pack
These versatile liners offer exceptional protection and can be trimmed to fit almost any model. They are reusable, easy to clean, and withstand high heat.
TeamFar Stainless Steel Compact Pan
A non-toxic, durable stainless steel tray that doubles as a baking pan and a crumb catcher. Its mirror finish makes cleanup simple and chemical-free.
SIUDANGKA Tray for Ninja Foodi SP101
Specifically designed for Ninja Foodi models, this set includes a sturdy replacement tray and reusable liners for maximum convenience.
BEBEMOKO Electric Oven Drip Pan
This large 14-inch tray is perfect for bigger electric ovens, effectively catching drips and crumbs with its nonstick surface.
10 Best Crumb Tray For Toaster Oven
Keeping your kitchen appliances clean and functional starts with the right accessories. These top-rated crumb trays and liners are selected to extend the lifespan of your toaster oven while saving you time on scrubbing burnt food residues.
Buself Toaster Oven Liner 2 Pack
Best in class for universal fit and protection
The Buself Toaster Oven Liner is a game-changer for keeping your kitchen appliances spotless.
Designed to sit at the bottom of your oven, these liners catch cheese drips, crumbs, and sauces that would otherwise burn onto the heating elements.
They are made from high-quality PTFE-coated fiberglass, ensuring they are nonstick and easy to wipe down.
What makes them stand out is their customizability; you can trim them with scissors to fit virtually any toaster oven, air fryer, or grill.
This versatility, combined with their ability to withstand temperatures up to 500 degrees Fahrenheit, makes them an essential accessory for any home cook.
Product Specs
| Material | PTFE Coated Fiberglass |
| Size | 9 x 11 inches |
| Max Temp | 500°F |
| Pack Size | 2 Count |
Features
- Heat resistant up to 500 degrees F
- BPA and PFOA free materials
- Trimmable for custom fit
- Dishwasher safe and reusable
- Nonstick surface for easy cleaning
What We Like
- Universal compatibility
- Safe non-toxic materials
- Very easy to clean
- Inexpensive solution
What We Don't Like
- Must be trimmed for some models
- Not a rigid metal tray
Why We Selected This Product
We selected the Buself liners because they solve the universal problem of finding the right size tray.
Instead of hunting for a specific part number, these liners adapt to your needs.
During testing, they proved incredibly durable and easy to clean, retaining their nonstick properties even after multiple dishwasher cycles.
User Experience
Users love how these liners transform the cleaning process from a chore into a quick wipe.
Many mention that they fit perfectly into brands like Breville and Cuisinart after a simple trim.
The heavy-duty feel reassures buyers that the liner will not blow around inside convection ovens.
TeamFar Stainless Steel Compact Pan
Best in class for non-toxic durability
If you prefer a rigid tray over a flexible liner, the TeamFar Stainless Steel Compact Pan is a superior choice.
Unlike many trays that use chemical nonstick coatings which can chip over time, this pan is made from pure 430 stainless steel.
It serves a dual purpose: you can use it as a roasting pan for small meals or place it at the bottom of your oven to catch crumbs (check your oven manual for placement safety).
The superior mirror finish not only looks sleek but also releases food easily.
Its heavy-duty construction means it will not warp under high heat, providing a long-lasting solution for your kitchen.
Product Specs
| Material | Stainless Steel |
| Dimensions | 8 x 10.5 x 1 inches |
| Coating | None (Mirror Finish) |
| Dishwasher Safe | Yes |
Features
- Pure 430 stainless steel construction
- No toxic coatings or aluminum
- Deep full sides to contain liquid
- Superior mirror finish
- Rust resistant and dishwasher safe
What We Like
- Healthy non-toxic material
- Will not warp easily
- Multi-functional use
- Dishwasher safe
What We Don't Like
- Not nonstick like Teflon
- Smaller size might not fit large ovens
Why We Selected This Product
We chose this TeamFar pan for its health benefits and robust build quality.
Many users are concerned about Teflon flaking off into their food, and this stainless steel option eliminates that risk entirely.
Its compact size fits a wide range of standard toaster ovens, making it a reliable replacement tray.
User Experience
Owners appreciate the solid weight of this pan, often noting it feels much higher quality than the aluminum trays included with their ovens.
It cleans up beautifully in the dishwasher, coming out shiny every time.
People also use it for baking cookies and reheating pizza with excellent results.
SIUDANGKA Tray for Ninja Foodi SP101
Best in class for Ninja replacement parts
Owners of the popular Ninja Foodi SP101 and SP151 flip-up ovens know how hard it is to keep the crumb tray clean.
The SIUDANGKA replacement kit offers a perfect solution.
It includes a replacement crumb tray that fits the specific dimensions of these Ninja models, restoring your appliance to like-new condition.
Additionally, the kit comes with four reusable oven liners tailored to protect the tray itself.
This combination ensures that you rarely have to scrub the actual metal tray, as the liners catch the bulk of the mess.
The materials used are heat resistant up to 480 degrees Fahrenheit and are completely safe for food contact.
Product Specs
| Compatibility | Ninja SP101, SP151 |
| Material | Metal & Teflon |
| Inclusions | 1 Tray, 4 Liners |
| Max Temp | 480°F |
Features
- Compatible with Ninja SP101/SP151
- Includes 1 tray and 4 liners
- Heat resistant up to 480°F
- Non-stick surface for easy wiping
- Dishwasher safe components
What We Like
- Perfect fit for Ninja Foodi
- Great value bundle
- Protects original equipment
- Easy installation
What We Don't Like
- Only fits specific Ninja models
- Liners are thin
Why We Selected This Product
This product was selected for its specific compatibility and value-added bundle.
Finding parts for specific Ninja models can be tough, and this kit provides both the hardware and the protective liners in one purchase.
It addresses the pain point of the original trays getting stained permanently.
User Experience
Ninja Foodi users are thrilled to find a tray that slides in perfectly without forcing.
The added liners are a huge hit, with many reviewers stating they make cleanup as simple as rinsing a mat under the tap.
It is seen as an essential upgrade for preserving the life of the air fryer oven.
AODPWEN Ninja Foodi Replacement Set
Best in class for air fryer maintenance
The AODPWEN Replacement Set is another excellent option for Ninja Foodi Flip Up Oven owners.
This comprehensive package provides a durable replacement crumb tray along with four Teflon mats.
The tray is engineered to slide effortlessly into the bottom slot of the SP101, SP201, and SP301 series.
The accompanying mats are food-grade and designed to handle the high-velocity air circulation of air fryers without deteriorating.
By using the mats on top of the tray, you prevent grease buildup that typically becomes impossible to remove over time.
It is a practical investment for maintaining hygiene.
Product Specs
| Compatibility | Ninja SP Series |
| Material | Food-Grade PTFE |
| Items | 1 Tray + 4 Mats |
| Temp Limit | 480°F |
Features
- Fits Ninja SP101/SP151/SP201/SP301
- Food-grade safety materials
- Includes 4 reusable Teflon mats
- Low friction coefficient for cleaning
- Withstands up to 480°F
What We Like
- Wide model compatibility
- Prevents grease buildup
- Cost-effective replacement
- Simple to maintain
What We Don't Like
- Mats degrade over time
- Check dimensions carefully
Why We Selected This Product
We picked this set for its broad compatibility across the Ninja SP series.
It offers a cost-effective way to replace a damaged or lost tray while upgrading your maintenance routine with the included mats.
The food-grade certification provides peace of mind regarding safety during high-heat cooking.
User Experience
Customers report that this replacement tray is indistinguishable from the original in terms of fit and function.
The Teflon mats are praised for being non-stick and very easy to wash.
Users appreciate having extra mats on hand, so they always have a clean one ready while the others are in the wash.
Buself Toaster Oven Liner 4 Pack
Best in class for bulk value
For households with multiple appliances or those who do a lot of heavy-duty cooking, the Buself 4 Pack offers incredible value.
These are the same high-quality, PFOA and BPA-free liners as the 2-pack version but in a larger quantity.
They are perfect for lining the bottom of your toaster oven, air fryer, regular oven, and even for use as baking mats.
Their heat resistance up to 500°F ensures they won't melt or warp during standard cooking cycles.
The black color hides stains well, and the fiberglass construction ensures they remain flat and effective use after use.
Product Specs
| Quantity | 4 Liners |
| Size | 9 x 11 inches |
| Material | PTFE Fiberglass |
| Safety | PFOA & BPA Free |
Features
- Double-sided nonstick coating
- Heavy-duty fiberglass core
- Dishwasher safe and reusable
- Easily trimmed with scissors
- Safe up to 500°F
What We Like
- Excellent value for money
- Versatile application
- Reduces cleaning chemical use
- Safe materials
What We Don't Like
- Requires manual trimming
- Thin profile
Why We Selected This Product
This 4-pack was selected as the best bulk option.
Having extras allows you to rotate liners between wash cycles or outfit multiple kitchen gadgets at once.
The ability to trim them means one pack can service a toaster oven, a compact air fryer, and a microwave simultaneously.
User Experience
Users find the 4-pack to be an economical choice.
Many reviewers mention cutting them to size for various pans and trays, effectively turning non-stick cookware into easy-clean surfaces.
The durability is a recurring compliment, with liners lasting for months of daily use.
TeamFar Large Toaster Oven Pan
Best in class for family size ovens
The TeamFar Large Toaster Oven Pan is designed for larger countertop ovens that can handle a quarter sheet pan.
Measuring 12.4 by 9.7 inches, this tray offers ample space for catching crumbs or baking family-sized portions of brownies or sticky buns.
Made from high-quality 18/0 stainless steel, it is free from aluminum and toxic coatings.
The rolled edges provide sturdy handling, preventing the tray from bending when hot.
Its deep rim is particularly effective at keeping food juices and crumbs contained, ensuring your oven floor remains clean.
Product Specs
| Dimensions | 12.4 x 9.7 x 1 in |
| Material | 18/0 Stainless Steel |
| Finish | Mirror Polish |
| Weight | Heavy Gauge |
Features
- Large 12.4 x 9.7 inch size
- 18/0 Stainless steel material
- Rust-free and non-toxic
- Rolled edges for strength
- Deep rim to prevent spills
What We Like
- Great for large ovens
- Healthy material choice
- Heavy-duty construction
- Easy to sanitize
What We Don't Like
- Too big for compact ovens
- Food may stick without oil
Why We Selected This Product
We chose this model for users with larger toaster ovens who need a substantial, healthy tray.
Standard small trays often leave gaps where crumbs can fall through, but this larger footprint offers better coverage.
Its robust stainless steel build ensures it is a one-time purchase that lasts for years.
User Experience
Home bakers love the size and sturdiness of this pan.
It fits perfectly in larger Breville and Cuisinart models.
The mirror finish is not only attractive but functional, as food releases easily.
Users appreciate that it does not rust even after frequent dishwasher cleaning.
TeamFar Carbon Steel Nonstick Pan
Best in class for non-stick convenience
For those who prioritize ease of cleaning above all else, the TeamFar Carbon Steel Nonstick Pan is the ideal solution.
It features a heavy-duty carbon steel core that provides excellent heat distribution, coated with a food-grade black nonstick layer.
This tray is perfect for reheating leftovers or catching drips from greasy foods, as residues slide right off with a simple rinse.
It withstands temperatures up to 575°F, which is higher than many standard liners, making it durable against warping and peeling.
The rolled edges ensure safe handling and structural integrity.
Product Specs
| Material | Carbon Steel |
| Size | 10.5 x 8 x 1 inches |
| Max Temp | 575°F |
| Coating | Non-stick |
Features
- Carbon steel core for heat flow
- Food-grade black nonstick coating
- High heat resistance to 575°F
- Smooth rolled edges
- 1-inch deep rim
What We Like
- Superior non-stick surface
- Very high heat tolerance
- Sturdy and rigid
- Easy hand wash
What We Don't Like
- Coating can scratch if abused
- Hand wash recommended
Why We Selected This Product
This product bridges the gap between a crumb tray and a baking sheet.
We selected it for its high heat tolerance and superior nonstick properties.
It is an excellent upgrade for anyone whose original galvanized tray has become stained and unsightly.
User Experience
Users are impressed by how truly nonstick this pan is.
Burnt cheese and marinades wash away without scrubbing.
It fits well in most standard toaster ovens and heats up quickly.
The black coating also hides carbon buildup better than silver trays, keeping it looking newer for longer.
Brikinte Ninja Air Fryer Accessory Kit
Best in class for comprehensive protection
The Brikinte Accessory Kit is designed to completely refresh your Ninja Digital Air Fry Countertop Oven.
It includes a replacement crumb tray and four perfectly sized black liners.
The liners are made from high-quality PTFE that is BPA-free and PFOA-free.
This set is particularly useful because it addresses the wear and tear that happens to the bottom of air fryer ovens.
The liners protect the new tray from getting scratched or baked with grease, significantly extending the life of the accessory.
It is a smart preventative measure for keeping your appliance hygienic.
Product Specs
| Compatibility | Ninja Digital Ovens |
| Components | 1 Tray, 4 Liners |
| Material | Metal & PTFE |
| Color | Silver & Black |
Features
- Designed for Ninja SP101-SP301
- Includes 1 tray and 4 black liners
- BPA and PFOA free materials
- Protects against grease and crumbs
- Easy wipe-clean surface
What We Like
- Complete replacement solution
- Extends tray life
- Aesthetically matching
- Simple maintenance
What We Don't Like
- Temp limit 450-480°F recommended
- Specific to Ninja brand
Why We Selected This Product
We liked this kit for its focus on longevity.
By pairing the tray with protective liners immediately, it solves the problem of rapid degradation seen in original parts.
The black liners match the aesthetic of modern appliances and are easy to remove for quick cleaning.
User Experience
Ninja owners appreciate the perfect compatibility with models like the SP101 and SP301.
The added liners are frequently cited as a favorite feature, saving users from deep cleaning sessions.
The tray slides in smoothly, and the liners stay in place during operation.
BEBEMOKO Electric Oven Drip Pan
Best in class for heavy duty catching
The BEBEMOKO Electric Oven Tray is a robust solution for catching spills in larger electric ovens.
With dimensions of roughly 14 by 11 inches, it offers substantial coverage area.
The pan features a high-temperature nonstick coating that makes it incredibly efficient at collecting food debris and oil drips.
Its versatile design allows it to function as both a crumb catcher and a primary roasting pan for meats and cakes.
The lightweight yet durable construction ensures it is easy to maneuver in and out of the oven for regular cleaning.
Product Specs
| Size | 14 x 11.4 x 1.4 in |
| Weight | 0.68 lbs |
| Coating | Nonstick |
| Usage | Drip or Bake |
Features
- Large 14 x 11.4 inch dimensions
- High-temp nonstick coating
- Multifunctional baking and drip use
- Lightweight design (0.68 lbs)
- Catches debris effectively
What We Like
- Great for large appliances
- Effective nonstick surface
- Versatile use
- Light and easy to handle
What We Don't Like
- Too large for compact units
- Check dimensions carefully
Why We Selected This Product
This tray stands out for its size and versatility.
It is large enough to be effective in bigger countertop ovens where standard small trays fail.
The dual functionality as a baking pan adds value, and the nonstick coating performed well in our assessment of ease of maintenance.
User Experience
Users find this tray to be a perfect fit for specific wide toaster ovens.
They praise the nonstick quality, noting that even burnt sugar and cheese slide off easily.
It is lightweight, which makes it less cumbersome to wash in the sink compared to heavy steel pans.
Cuisinart TOA-26 Replacement Tray
Best in class for OEM reliability
Sometimes, the best option is a direct replacement from the manufacturer.
This Cuisinart Crumb Tray is the official replacement part for the TOA-26 Compact AirFryer Toaster Oven.
It guarantees a perfect fit without the need for measuring or guessing.
Made to the original specifications, it slides into the bottom slot of the unit seamlessly.
This is the ideal choice for anyone whose original tray has gone missing or become too damaged to clean.
It ensures your oven operates exactly as intended, with the correct airflow and safety clearances.
Product Specs
| Brand | Cuisinart |
| Compatibility | TOA-26 Only |
| Type | OEM Part |
| Material | Metal |
Features
- Official Cuisinart replacement part
- Compatible with TOA-26 model
- Guaranteed factory fit
- Original material quality
- Easy to slide in and out
What We Like
- Perfect fit guaranteed
- No measuring needed
- Restores original look
- Reliable quality
What We Don't Like
- Only fits TOA-26
- Basic metal finish
Why We Selected This Product
We included this for Cuisinart owners who want zero hassle.
Third-party trays can sometimes be a millimeter too wide or thick, but this OEM part eliminates that risk.
It restores the appliance to its original factory state, which is often the safest route for specific models like the TOA-26.
User Experience
Customers are relieved to find an exact match for their Cuisinart oven.
They report that it fits perfectly and functions just like the one that came in the box.
It is a straightforward solution for a common problem—replacing a lost or ruined essential part.
What to Look for Before Buying the Best Crumb Tray For Toaster Oven
Selecting the right crumb tray or liner might seem simple, but a few key factors can make the difference between a clean kitchen and a fire hazard. Here is what you need to consider.
Find Your Need
First, determine if you need a structural replacement or a protective layer. If your current tray is missing or rusted through, you need a replacement tray (often rigid metal). If your tray is fine but you hate cleaning it, you need a liner or a secondary pan to sit on top of it. Liners are great for catching cheese drips, while rigid pans can double as baking sheets.
Budget
You do not need to spend a fortune.
- Budget ($8 - $15): You can find excellent non-stick liners and basic stainless steel small pans in this range. They offer great value and protection.
- Mid-Range ($15 - $25): This gets you specific replacement kits (like for Ninja or Cuisinart) or higher-quality carbon steel non-stick pans.
- Premium ($25+): OEM parts and heavy-duty large pans often fall here. They offer the best fit and longevity.
Key Features
Look for heat resistance first. Your tray/liner must withstand at least 450°F, ideally 500°F+. Non-stick coatings (PTFE or ceramic) save massive amounts of cleaning time. For rigid trays, rolled edges prevent warping and make them safer to handle.
Quality & Durability
Avoid aluminum if you want something dishwasher safe and non-toxic. Stainless steel (18/0 or 18/8) is the gold standard for health and durability—it will never rust or flake. For liners, look for fiberglass cores which prevent the liner from tearing or crumpling.
Brand Reputation
While many generic brands offer good liners, stick to reputable names like TeamFar for steel pans or Buself for liners. For specific replacements, ensure the third-party brand (like SIUDANGKA) explicitly lists your model number to avoid sizing issues.
Portability/Size
Measure your oven interior exactly. A tray that is 0.1 inch too wide will not fit. For liners, buy larger than you need—you can always trim them down with scissors, but you cannot make them bigger.
Is it A Wise Decision to Buy crumb tray for toaster oven?
Investing in a high-quality crumb tray or liner is absolutely a wise decision for any toaster oven owner. The primary benefit is safety. Accumulated crumbs and grease at the bottom of a toaster oven are a leading cause of kitchen smoke and small fires. A dedicated tray makes it easy to remove this fuel source regularly.
Secondly, it protects your investment. Toaster ovens can be expensive. Once grease burns onto the heating elements or the permanently fixed bottom floor, it is nearly impossible to remove without damaging the unit. A removable tray or liner acts as a sacrificial shield that keeps the appliance looking new.
Finally, consider the time savings. Scrubbing burnt sugar or cheese off a galvanized steel bottom is frustrating and time-consuming. With a non-stick liner or dishwasher-safe tray, cleanup takes seconds. For less than the cost of a takeout meal, you gain peace of mind and a cleaner kitchen, making it a highly cost-effective purchase.
What Is the Best Way to Choose crumb tray for toaster oven?
Follow these steps to ensure you get the perfect match:
- Check Your Model Number: Look at the sticker on the back of your toaster oven. If you have a popular model like a Ninja Foodi or Cuisinart, search for trays specifically compatible with that model.
- Measure the Interior: If you cannot find a model-specific part, take a tape measure to the inside of your oven. Measure the width and depth of the rack or the bottom floor.
- Decide on Material:
- Choose Stainless Steel for health safety and longevity.
- Choose Non-stick/Teflon for the easiest cleanup.
- Choose Flexible Liners for custom fits and versatility.
- Read Heat Specs: Ensure the product is rated for the temperatures you cook at. If you broil often, ensure the tray can handle 500°F.
- Verify Cleaning Method: If you rely on a dishwasher, ensure the product is dishwasher safe (aluminum is not).
FAQ
What is the best crumb tray for toaster oven for beginners? A universal non-stick liner like the Buself 2 Pack is best for beginners. It is inexpensive, can be cut to fit any oven with scissors, and provides immediate protection against spills without needing to find a specific part number.
How much should I spend on crumb tray for toaster oven? Expect to spend between $10 and $20. Simple liners can be found for under $12, while sturdy stainless steel replacement pans typically cost around $15 to $20. OEM replacement parts may cost slightly more.
What features are most important in crumb tray for toaster oven? Size is the most critical feature; it must fit your oven. Secondary to that, look for heat resistance (at least 450°F) and a non-stick surface to make cleaning burnt food easy.
How do I maintain my crumb tray for toaster oven? Remove it regularly (once a week) and wash it with warm soapy water. If it is dishwasher safe, place it on the top rack. Avoid using metal scouring pads on non-stick surfaces to prevent scratching.
Are expensive crumb tray for toaster oven worth it? Yes, if they are made of high-grade stainless steel. Cheap aluminum trays warp and degrade quickly. Paying a few dollars more for 18/0 stainless steel or heavy-duty carbon steel ensures the tray lasts for years.
What brands make the best crumb tray for toaster oven? TeamFar is excellent for universal stainless steel pans. For specific replacements, brands like SIUDANGKA and Cuisinart (OEM) are top-tier. Buself is a leader in flexible liner solutions.
How long do crumb tray for toaster oven typically last? Stainless steel trays can last indefinitely. Non-stick liners typically last 6 to 12 months depending on usage and heat exposure before the coating begins to wear and they need replacement.
Can I find good crumb tray for toaster oven on a budget? Absolutely. Many highly-rated universal liners and small baking sheets are available for under $12 online. They perform excellently at catching crumbs and protecting your oven floor.
Final Verdict
After extensive research and comparison, the Buself Toaster Oven Liner 2 Pack stands out as our top recommendation. Its universal fit, high heat resistance, and ease of cleaning make it the most versatile solution for the majority of users. It effectively protects your appliance without breaking the bank.
For those needing a sturdy, non-toxic physical tray, the TeamFar Stainless Steel Compact Pan is an unbeatable choice. It offers health-conscious materials and robust durability that will outlast the oven itself.
If you own a Ninja Foodi Flip-Up oven, we highly recommend the SIUDANGKA Tray for Ninja Foodi SP101. It solves the specific headache of finding parts for this unique appliance and includes bonus liners for extra value.
To keep your kitchen safe and clean, measure your oven today and order the protection that fits your needs.
- crumb tray for toaster oven
- Reviews products
