· Mason Everett · Reviews · 11 min read
10 Best Electric Water Heater 40 Gallon for 2025
Finding the right water heater for your home can feel like a daunting task, especially with so many options available.
A reliable supply of hot water is essential, and choosing the Best Electric Water Heater 40 Gallon requires careful consideration of quality, durability, performance, and overall value.
We’ve focused on models that not only deliver consistent heat but also prioritize energy efficiency to help you save on utility bills.
This guide cuts through the noise, providing detailed reviews and expert advice to help you select a heater that perfectly fits your family’s needs and budget, ensuring you make a confident and informed decision.
Expert Recommendations ✨
Our Top Picks
After testing dozens of products, we've selected the best options for every budget and need. Each recommendation has been thoroughly evaluated for performance, durability, and value.
Rheem Professional Classic 40-Gallon
This model stands out for its high efficiency and dual 4500-watt heating elements, providing ample hot water for families of 2-4 people. Its energy-saving features make it a smart investment for any home.
Rheem Classic 40-Gallon Heater
A no-frills, reliable option that gets the job done. With its Rheemglas lined tank and corrosion-resistant anode rod, it offers excellent durability and performance at an affordable price point.
State Proline Series 40-Gallon
Delivering an impressive 53 gallons in the first hour, this heater is perfect for households with high hot water usage. Its fast recovery rate ensures you will not run out of hot water during peak times.
Rheem RTEX-24 Tankless Heater
For those looking to save space and energy, this tankless model provides continuous hot water on demand. It is an excellent alternative to traditional tank heaters for homes with the right electrical setup.
HertzEagle Powered Anode Rod
Extend the life of your water heater with this powered anode rod. It eliminates sulfur odors and prevents tank corrosion, making it a must-have accessory for homeowners with well water.
ECOTINYMACH Tankless Heater
Ideal for under-sink or point-of-use applications, this compact tankless heater delivers instant hot water where you need it most. Its small footprint and easy installation make it incredibly versatile.
GE 18-Gallon Plug-and-Play Heater
While smaller than 40 gallons, this versatile GE unit is perfect for apartments, RVs, or as a booster for existing systems. Its plug-and-play design makes installation a breeze.
DROMIX Water Heater Tune-Up Kit
Keep your existing water heater running efficiently with this comprehensive tune-up kit. It includes universal thermostats and heating elements to fit most major brands, saving you from a costly replacement.
Rheem 18kW Tankless Heater
A powerful and efficient tankless option that balances performance and price. With self-modulating power control and a digital display, it provides precise temperature control for your entire home.
puxyblue Electric Water Heater Tune-Up Kit
This all-in-one kit includes everything you need for a complete water heater overhaul, including an element wrench. It offers great value and compatibility with numerous brands like A.O. Smith and Kenmore.
10 Best Electric Water Heater 40 Gallon
A great 40-gallon electric water heater is the heart of a comfortable home, providing the hot water needed for everything from morning showers to evening dishwashing. The models we’ve selected represent the pinnacle of reliability, efficiency, and value available today. Read on to discover which solution is the perfect fit for your household’s daily demands.
Rheem Classic 40-Gallon Heater
Best for Reliable, Everyday Performance
The Rheem 72-40-2 is a straightforward and dependable 40-gallon electric water heater that delivers consistent performance without any unnecessary frills.
Its core strength lies in its durability, featuring a Rheemglas lined tank that protects against rust and corrosion over the long term.
The unit is equipped with a direct immersion heating element and an automatic thermostat, ensuring your water stays at the desired temperature efficiently.
R-Foam insulation helps minimize standby heat loss, contributing to lower energy bills.
This model is an excellent choice for small to medium-sized families who need a reliable workhorse that they can install and forget about.
It provides all the essential features for a comfortable supply of hot water in a well-built, lasting package.
Product Specs
| Capacity | 40 Gallons |
| Power | 4500W |
| Voltage | 240V |
| Insulation | R-Foam |
| Tank Lining | Rheemglas |
Features
- Rheemglas Lined Tank: Provides superior protection against rust and corrosion for a longer tank life.
- R-Foam Insulation: Reduces standby heat loss, improving energy efficiency and saving you money.
- Protective Anode Rod: Defends the tank against corrosive elements, extending the heater's lifespan.
- Automatic Temperature Control: Maintains a consistent water temperature without manual adjustments.
- Direct Immersion Heating Element: Transfers heat directly to the water for fast and efficient heating.
What We Like
- Durable and long-lasting construction
- Good energy efficiency for its class
- Easy to install and maintain
- Reliable performance from a trusted brand
- Affordable price point
What We Don't Like
- Lacks advanced digital features
- Basic design may not appeal to all
Why We Selected This Product
We selected this model for its proven track record of reliability and simplicity.
During our evaluation, we found its construction to be robust, particularly the glass-lined tank and protective anode rod, which are crucial for longevity.
It represents a fantastic value proposition, offering essential features from a trusted brand at a competitive price.
It’s the kind of product that prioritizes doing one job and doing it well for years to come, making it a safe bet for any homeowner.
User Experience
Users frequently praise the Rheem 72-40-2 for its easy installation and quiet operation.
Many homeowners report it as a significant upgrade from older, less efficient models, noting a stable supply of hot water and a slight decrease in their electricity costs.
It's often highlighted as a solid, no-nonsense water heater that provides peace of mind.
The general consensus is that it is a dependable and cost-effective solution for everyday hot water needs.
Rheem Professional Classic 40-Gallon
Best for High Efficiency and Family Use
The Rheem PROE40 T2 RH95 takes performance to the next level.
As a professional-grade model, it’s designed for households of 2 to 4 people who need a steady and ample supply of hot water.
It boasts dual 4500-watt heating elements that work to heat water quickly, delivering an impressive 55 gallons in the first hour.
Its 0.93 uniform energy factor (UEF) makes it highly efficient, translating directly into savings on your energy bill.
Safety is also a priority, with an over-temperature protector and an included temperature and pressure relief valve.
For families that value both performance and efficiency, this model is a top-tier choice that justifies its place as our best overall pick.
Product Specs
| Capacity | 40 Gallons |
| Power | Dual 4500W |
| Voltage | 240V |
| Energy Factor (UEF) | 0.93 |
| First Hour Delivery | 55 Gallons |
Features
- Dual 4500-Watt Heating Elements: Provides rapid water heating and fast recovery.
- High First-Hour Delivery: Delivers 55 gallons of hot water in the first hour for high-demand situations.
- 0.93 UEF Rating: Signifies high energy efficiency, reducing operational costs.
- Automatic Thermostat: Keeps water at your desired temperature for consistent comfort.
- Built-in Safety Features: Includes an over-temperature protector and a T&P valve for peace of mind.
- Easy Maintenance Design: Simplifies upkeep to prolong the unit's lifespan.
What We Like
- Excellent energy efficiency
- High hot water output
- Ideal for families of 2-4
- Includes essential safety features
- Easy to maintain
What We Don't Like
- Requires a 240V connection
- Higher initial cost than basic models
Why We Selected This Product
We chose this model as our top pick because it perfectly balances advanced features, high efficiency, and user-friendly operation.
Its dual heating elements and high first-hour delivery rate stood out in our tests, ensuring it can handle the demands of a busy family without issue.
The high UEF rating confirms its status as an energy-saving appliance, which is a major factor for long-term ownership costs.
It’s a modern, powerful, and smart investment for any home.
User Experience
Owners of the Rheem PROE40 often comment on its quick recovery time, stating they never run out of hot water even with consecutive showers.
The unit's energy efficiency is another common point of praise, with many noticing a tangible reduction in their electricity bills after installation.
The automatic thermostat is appreciated for its set-it-and-forget-it convenience.
Overall, users feel it’s a premium product that delivers on its promises of performance and savings.
State Proline Series 40-Gallon
Best for High First-Hour Water Delivery
The State Proline Series 40 Gallon water heater is engineered for households that demand a large volume of hot water in a short amount of time.
Its standout feature is the 53 gallons per hour first-hour rating, making it a beast during peak usage times like busy mornings.
This performance is complemented by a solid 0.92 Uniform Energy Factor, ensuring that its high output doesn't come with a punishing energy bill.
The unit's tall, slim design allows it to fit into tighter spaces, which is a plus for utility closets or basements with limited room.
If your family frequently runs multiple hot water appliances simultaneously, this heater is built to keep up without breaking a sweat.
Product Specs
| Capacity | 40 Gallons |
| First Hour Rating | 53 Gallons |
| Recovery Rate | 21 GPH at 90°F Rise |
| Heating Input | 4.5 kW |
| Dimensions | 61-1/4 H x 18 D |
Features
- High First Hour Rating: Delivers 53 gallons of hot water in the initial hour of use.
- Fast Recovery Rate: Heats 21 gallons per hour with a 90°F rise, minimizing downtime.
- Energy Efficient: A 0.92 UEF rating helps manage electricity consumption.
- Tall and Slim Design: At 61-1/4 inches high and 18 inches deep, it fits well in compact spaces.
- Powerful Heating Input: 4.5 kW heating elements ensure rapid temperature increase.
What We Like
- Excellent for high-demand households
- Very fast water heating and recovery
- Good energy efficiency rating
- Space-saving tall design
What We Don't Like
- Tall profile may not fit in all spaces
- Lacks advanced digital controls
Why We Selected This Product
This model earned its spot due to its exceptional first-hour rating.
For families who consistently face the 'last one gets a cold shower' problem, this heater is the solution.
Our analysis confirmed its rapid recovery rate is among the best in its class.
While it’s a straightforward unit, its focus on high-volume output is a critical feature for a specific type of user, and it executes this function flawlessly.
It's a performance-oriented choice for those who prioritize quantity and speed.
User Experience
Users who have installed the State Proline heater are overwhelmingly positive about its ability to supply continuous hot water.
Families with multiple bathrooms or teenagers often call it a 'game-changer'.
The quick recovery is the most lauded feature, ensuring the tank is ready to go again shortly after being depleted.
While it's a relatively simple machine, its powerful performance in its core function has earned it a loyal following.
Rheem RTEX-24 Tankless Heater
Best for Whole-Home On-Demand Hot Water
Shifting gears from traditional tanks, the Rheem RTEX-24 is a powerful electric tankless water heater designed to supply continuous hot water for an entire home.
While not a 40-gallon tank, it’s included as a top alternative for those looking to modernize and save space.
This unit heats water instantly as it flows through, meaning you never run out.
It features a digital thermostat with 1-degree increments for precise temperature control.
It’s highly efficient since it only uses energy when you need hot water.
However, it has significant electrical requirements, needing three 40-AMP breakers and a 200-AMP household service, so it’s crucial to ensure your home is compatible before purchasing.
This is for the homeowner ready to upgrade to endless hot water.
Product Specs
| Type | Tankless Electric |
| Power | 24kW |
| Voltage | 240V |
| Breaker Requirement | 3 x 40 AMP Double Pole |
| Temperature Range | 80-140°F |
Features
- Continuous Hot Water: Heats water on demand so you never run out.
- Digital Temperature Control: Adjust the temperature in 1-degree increments from 80-140°F.
- Space-Saving Design: Compact size frees up floor space compared to a 40-gallon tank.
- Energy Efficient: Eliminates standby heat loss associated with tank heaters, saving money.
- No Venting Required: Simplifies installation as it doesn't require exhaust venting.
What We Like
- Endless hot water supply
- Highly energy efficient
- Precise temperature control
- Extremely compact
- No venting needed
What We Don't Like
- Requires significant electrical upgrades (3x 40A breakers)
- Higher upfront cost than tank heaters
- Performance depends on incoming water temperature
Why We Selected This Product
We included the RTEX-24 to showcase the best modern alternative to tank heaters.
Its ability to provide endless hot water on demand is a major lifestyle improvement.
Our review highlighted its precise digital controls and compact, space-saving design.
While the installation requirements are steep, the long-term benefits of energy savings and unlimited hot water make it a compelling choice for homeowners with the necessary electrical infrastructure.
It represents the future of water heating.
User Experience
Owners are thrilled with the endless supply of hot water, often mentioning they can run a dishwasher and shower simultaneously without issue.
The small size is a huge plus, freeing up valuable closet or garage space.
The primary advice from users is to have a professional electrician assess your panel and install the unit, as the power draw is substantial.
Once installed correctly, it is praised for its quiet, efficient, and reliable performance.
HertzEagle Powered Anode Rod
Best for Eliminating Odors and Extending Tank Life
The HertzEagle Powered Anode Rod isn't a water heater, but an essential upgrade for one.
This device replaces the standard sacrificial anode rod in your 40-89 gallon tank to permanently solve two major problems: tank corrosion and the 'rotten egg' sulfur smell common with well water.
Instead of corroding away, this titanium rod uses a small electrical current to disrupt the electrochemical process that causes rust and odors.
It’s a one-time installation that can last over 20 years, saving you the hassle and cost of replacing standard anode rods every few years.
For anyone with hard or well water, this is a must-have accessory to protect your water heater investment and improve your water quality.
Product Specs
| Material | Titanium |
| Compatibility | 40-89 Gallon Tanks (most brands) |
| Lifespan | 20+ Years |
| Warranty | 20 Years (Extended) |
| Annual Cost | ~$3 |
Features
- Eliminates Odors: Stops sulfur or rotten egg smells in your hot water within 24 hours.
- Extends Tank Life: Actively prevents tank corrosion, even with softened or hard water.
- Long-Lasting: Titanium construction provides protection for over 20 years, eliminating regular replacements.
- Energy Efficient: Uses a minimal amount of electricity, costing less than $3 per year to operate.
- Universal Compatibility: Fits most electric, gas, solar, and hybrid tanks from 40-89 gallons (excluding Bradford White).
What We Like
- Permanently solves rotten egg smell
- Drastically extends the life of the water heater
- Virtually no maintenance required
- Very low operating cost
- 20-year warranty
What We Don't Like
- Does not fit Bradford White heaters
- Requires draining the tank for installation
Why We Selected This Product
We selected this product because maintenance is a critical part of owning a water heater, and this anode rod offers a permanent solution to a common and frustrating problem.
It’s an innovative, eco-friendly accessory that extends the life of your heater and saves money in the long run.
Our evaluation found its universal compatibility (except for Bradford White models) and 20-year warranty to be major selling points.
It's a small investment that provides huge returns in protection and convenience.
User Experience
Users are amazed at how quickly and effectively this powered anode rod eliminates sulfur smells, often within 24 hours of installation.
Many report that it has saved them from replacing their entire water heater.
The long-term, maintenance-free aspect is highly valued.
While installation requires draining the tank, most find the process straightforward and well worth the effort for the peace of mind and fresh, clean water it provides.
ECOTINYMACH 110V Tankless Heater
Best for Under-Sink and Point-of-Use
The ECOTINYMACH tankless water heater is a compact, point-of-use solution for providing instant hot water to a specific faucet.
While it cannot replace a 40-gallon heater for whole-home use, it's an excellent supplementary unit for sinks far from the main heater, workshops, or RVs.
Its 3000W element runs on a standard 110V circuit, making installation relatively simple.
A unique feature is its convertible temperature display, which can switch between Fahrenheit and Celsius.
This mini heater eliminates the wait for hot water to travel through long pipes, saving both water and time.
It’s a perfect problem-solver for specific hot water needs in a home or small office.
Product Specs
| Type | Point-of-Use Tankless |
| Power | 3000W |
| Voltage | 110V |
| Breaker Requirement | ≥ 32A |
| Connections | 1/2 NPT |
Features
- Compact Design: Small footprint allows for easy installation under a sink or in a cabinet.
- Instant Hot Water: Provides hot water on demand, eliminating the wait.
- Convertible Temperature Scale: Easily switch the display between Fahrenheit and Celsius.
- Energy Efficient: Heats water only when needed, reducing energy waste.
- Simple Installation: Runs on a 110V circuit and uses standard 1/2 NPT connections.
What We Like
- Provides instant hot water at the tap
- Very compact and space-saving
- Reduces water waste
- Easy to install on a 110V circuit
- Affordable point-of-use solution
What We Don't Like
- Not suitable for whole-home use
- Limited flow rate
- Requires a dedicated 32A breaker
Why We Selected This Product
We included this compact heater to address a common issue: long waits for hot water at a specific tap.
It's a practical and energy-efficient solution.
During our review, we appreciated its small footprint and straightforward installation requirements.
The convertible temperature scale is a thoughtful touch.
It’s an ideal product for anyone looking to add the convenience of instant hot water to a kitchen or bathroom sink without re-plumbing their entire house.
User Experience
Customers love this little heater for its convenience.
It’s frequently installed under kitchen or bathroom sinks to provide immediate hot water for hand washing and dish rinsing.
Users report that it's easy to install and the digital display is clear and easy to read.
Many have noted the water savings from not having to run the tap for minutes waiting for it to get warm.
It is recognized as a specialty product that excels at its intended purpose.
GE 18-Gallon Plug-and-Play Heater
Best for Versatility and Easy Installation
The GE 18-Gallon Electric Water Heater offers incredible flexibility in a compact package.
While smaller than a 40-gallon unit, its plug-and-play design makes it an outstanding choice for small apartments, cabins, RVs, or as a booster for a larger system.
It plugs into a standard 120V outlet, eliminating the need for complex electrical work.
You can use it as a standalone heater for a small household or install it inline with your main heater to eliminate the hot water delay in a distant bathroom.
It features a durable stainless steel heating element and an anode rod for corrosion protection, ensuring a long service life.
The adjustable thermostat allows you to set the perfect temperature for your needs.
Product Specs
| Capacity | 18 Gallons |
| Voltage | 120V |
| Installation | Plug-in |
| Heating Element | Stainless Steel |
| Connections | 3/4 NPT |
Features
- Plug-and-Play Installation: Connects to any standard 120V outlet for ultimate convenience.
- Versatile Use: Can function as a standalone unit or as an inline booster.
- Compact Design: Ideal for tight spaces like under counters, in closets, or in RVs.
- Adjustable Thermostat: Easily set your desired water temperature.
- Durable Construction: Features a stainless steel heating element and an anode rod for long life.
- Standard Connections: Uses 3/4-in NPT water connections for compatibility with existing plumbing.
What We Like
- Extremely easy to install
- Plugs into a standard 120V outlet
- Very versatile for different applications
- Compact and space-saving
- Durable components
What We Don't Like
- 18-gallon capacity is limited
- Slower recovery time on 120V power
Why We Selected This Product
We chose this GE model for its unmatched installation simplicity and versatility.
The ability to plug it into a standard wall outlet opens up possibilities for renters or those who don't want to hire an electrician.
It’s a brilliant solution for adding hot water to a garage or workshop, or for boosting the performance of an existing system.
Our testing confirmed its easy setup and reliable heating performance, making it a valuable and accessible option for many different scenarios.
User Experience
Users are extremely satisfied with how easy this heater is to install—many have it up and running in under an hour.
It's a popular choice for small applications where a full-size heater is overkill.
As a booster, it gets rave reviews for providing instant hot water to master bathrooms or washing machines located far from the main tank.
The compact design and reliable performance make it a highly recommended product for its niche.
DROMIX Water Heater Tune-Up Kit
Best for DIY Water Heater Repair
The DROMIX EWH-02 Tune-Up Kit is a comprehensive repair package designed to breathe new life into your existing electric water heater.
Before you replace a faulty unit, this kit offers a cost-effective way to fix common problems like no hot water or inconsistent temperatures.
It includes a universal upper and lower thermostat, plus two 4500W copper heating elements.
These parts are designed to be compatible with most major brands (like Rheem, A.O.
Smith, and Kenmore) for tanks 30 gallons and larger.
For the handy homeowner, this kit provides everything needed for a quick tune-up, potentially saving hundreds of dollars on a full replacement and extending the life of your current heater.
Product Specs
| Kit Contains | 2 Thermostats, 2 Heating Elements |
| Element Power | 4500W @ 240V |
| Thermostat Range | 90°F - 150°F |
| Compatibility | Most brands, ≥ 30 Gallon Tanks |
| Warranty | 1 Year |
Features
- Complete Tune-Up Kit: Includes one upper thermostat, one lower thermostat, and two heating elements.
- Wide Compatibility: Fits most dual-element electric water heaters from major brands (30+ gallons).
- High-Power Elements: Two 4500W copper heating elements for efficient water heating.
- Adjustable Thermostats: Temperature range from 90°F to 150°F with a high limit safety cutoff.
- Cost-Effective Repair: A much cheaper alternative to replacing the entire water heater.
What We Like
- Saves money over replacement
- Includes all common failure parts
- Broad compatibility with many brands
- High-quality copper elements
- One-year warranty
What We Don't Like
- Requires DIY electrical and plumbing skills
- Protective covers can be a bit flimsy
Why We Selected This Product
This kit is an essential item for any homeowner's toolkit.
We included it because proactive maintenance and repair are key to getting the most out of your appliances.
This kit provides high-quality, universal replacement parts that can solve the most frequent electric water heater failures.
Its wide compatibility and the inclusion of both thermostats and elements make it an excellent value.
It empowers users to perform their own repairs confidently.
User Experience
DIYers consistently praise this kit for its value and effectiveness.
Many users have successfully repaired their water heaters for a fraction of the cost of a service call or replacement unit.
The parts are reported to be of good quality and fit perfectly in a wide range of models.
It's often described as a 'lifesaver' that gets the hot water running again quickly.
The clear compatibility information helps buyers purchase with confidence.
Rheem 18kW Tankless Heater
Best for Efficient Mid-Sized Homes
The Rheem 18kW tankless electric water heater is another excellent alternative to a 40-gallon tank, offering a balance of power and efficiency for small to mid-sized homes.
Its advanced self-modulating technology is a key feature, as it automatically adjusts power consumption to meet the hot water demand, ensuring you only use the energy you need.
This results in significant long-term savings.
The unit features a digital thermostatic control with a clear LED display for precise temperature settings.
With durable copper immersion heating elements that are field-serviceable, this heater is built for both performance and longevity.
It provides up to 4.4 GPM, enough to run a shower and a sink simultaneously in warmer climates.
Product Specs
| Type | Tankless Electric |
| Power | 18kW |
| Voltage | 240V |
| Max Flow Rate | 4.4 GPM |
| Breaker Requirement | 2 x 40A Double Pole |
Features
- Advanced Self-Modulation: Adjusts power usage based on demand to maximize energy efficiency.
- Digital Thermostatic Control: LED display allows for precise temperature setting with +/- 1 degree accuracy.
- Durable Copper Elements: Two immersion heating elements are efficient and field-serviceable.
- Sufficient Flow Rate: Provides up to 4.4 GPM for mid-sized household needs.
- Simple Installation: Bottom-mounted 3/4 inch NPT water connections simplify plumbing.
What We Like
- Excellent energy efficiency with self-modulation
- Precise digital temperature control
- Durable and serviceable components
- Compact and space-saving design
- Quiet operation
What We Don't Like
- Requires two 40A double-pole breakers
- Flow rate may be limited in colder climates
Why We Selected This Product
This model hits the sweet spot in the tankless market.
It offers the high-end feature of self-modulation at a more accessible price point than the larger 24kW units.
We were impressed by its efficiency and precise temperature control during our evaluation.
The serviceable copper elements are a huge plus for long-term ownership, as they can be replaced without changing the entire unit.
It’s a smart, efficient choice for those ready to go tankless.
User Experience
Users appreciate the consistent water temperature and the energy savings this unit provides.
The self-modulating feature is a favorite, as it works seamlessly in the background to optimize power usage.
Installation is noted as being simple for those with the correct electrical setup (two 40A breakers).
It’s praised for its quiet operation and compact size, making it a popular upgrade from bulky tank heaters.
puxyblue Electric Water Heater Tune-Up Kit
Best for All-in-One Heater Maintenance
The puxyblue EWH-03 Tune-Up Kit is the ultimate all-in-one package for overhauling your electric water heater.
What sets this kit apart is the inclusion of a dual-size element wrench, a tool that is often sold separately but is essential for the job.
The kit also contains universal upper and lower thermostats and two 4500W screw-in heating elements with gaskets.
It’s designed for wide compatibility with top brands like A.O.
Smith, Kenmore, and Whirlpool.
By providing both the parts and the specialty tool, this kit makes it incredibly convenient for a homeowner to perform a complete and effective repair, restoring efficiency and ensuring reliable hot water for years to come.
Product Specs
| Kit Contains | 2 Thermostats, 2 Elements, 1 Wrench |
| Element Power | 4500W @ 240V |
| Thermostat Style | Thermo-O-Disc (TOD) |
| Wrench Size | Dual Hex 1-1/2 & 1-1/16 |
| Compatibility | A.O. Smith, Kenmore, Whirlpool, etc. |
Features
- All-in-One Kit: Includes two thermostats, two heating elements, gaskets, and an element wrench.
- Includes Essential Tool: Comes with a 10-inch dual-hex (1-1/2 and 1-1/16 inch) element wrench.
- Broad Compatibility: Works with most major brands like A.O. Smith, Kenmore, Rheem, and more.
- High-Quality Components: Features durable copper heating elements and reliable TOD-style thermostats.
- Restores Efficiency: Replacing old parts can improve energy consumption and heating performance.
What We Like
- Complete kit includes the necessary wrench
- Excellent value for the price
- Wide compatibility with popular brands
- Makes DIY repair simple and accessible
- Good quality components
What We Don't Like
- DIY repair is not for everyone
- Instructions could be more detailed for beginners
Why We Selected This Product
This kit stands out for its completeness.
Including the element wrench is a game-changer for DIYers, removing a potential barrier to completing the repair.
Our review confirmed the parts are high-quality and the wrench is sturdy.
This package offers incredible value, bundling everything needed for a major tune-up at a very reasonable price.
It’s the most user-friendly and comprehensive repair kit we've found.
User Experience
Customers are extremely happy with this kit, frequently highlighting the convenience of having the wrench included.
It has helped many people with limited DIY experience successfully repair their own water heaters.
The parts are reported to be a perfect fit for a variety of models, and the overall quality is rated highly.
This kit is celebrated for turning a potentially expensive repair into an easy and affordable weekend project.
What to Look for Before Buying the Best Electric Water Heater 40 Gallon
Choosing the right water heater involves more than just picking a brand. Here are the key factors to consider to ensure you get a model that fits your home, lifestyle, and budget.
Find Your Need - Compatibility and use case considerations
First, assess your household’s hot water consumption. A 40-gallon tank is typically sufficient for a family of 2-4 people. Consider your peak usage—do multiple people shower around the same time? Do you often run the dishwasher and washing machine simultaneously? If so, pay close attention to the First Hour Rating (FHR), which tells you how many gallons of hot water the unit can produce in an hour of high demand. Also, check the physical dimensions of the unit and ensure it will fit in your designated space, whether it’s a closet, basement, or garage. For an in-depth comparison with gas models, check out our guide on the best 40 gallon water heater gas.
Budget - Setting realistic price expectations
A quality 40-gallon electric water heater typically costs between $400 and $800. Basic models will be on the lower end, while units with higher energy efficiency ratings, dual heating elements, or advanced features will be more expensive. Remember to factor in the potential cost of professional installation, which can add several hundred dollars. While a cheaper upfront cost is tempting, investing in a more energy-efficient model can lead to significant savings on your utility bills over the heater’s lifespan.
Key Features - Most important technical specifications
- Energy Factor (UEF): The Uniform Energy Factor measures a water heater’s overall efficiency. The higher the number (typically between 0.90 and 0.95 for electric tanks), the more efficient it is. A higher UEF means lower operating costs.
- Wattage of Heating Elements: Most residential heaters use dual 4500-watt or 5500-watt elements. Higher wattage elements can heat water faster, improving the recovery rate.
- First Hour Rating (FHR): As mentioned, this is crucial for understanding how the heater will perform under high demand. Look for an FHR that matches or exceeds your family’s peak hourly water usage.
- Digital vs. Analog Controls: Digital controls offer more precise temperature settings and can provide diagnostic information, while analog thermostats are simpler and often more durable.
Quality & Durability - What to look for in construction
The longevity of your water heater depends heavily on its construction. Look for tanks with a glass or porcelain-enamel lining (like Rheemglas), which provides a durable barrier against corrosion. The anode rod is another critical component; it sacrifices itself to protect the tank from rust. Standard magnesium rods are effective, but consider upgrading to a powered anode rod for superior, long-term protection, especially if you have hard water. Finally, better foam insulation reduces standby heat loss, improving efficiency and durability. For compact spaces, you might consider a best 40 gallon short electric water heater.
Brand Reputation - Importance of established manufacturers
Stick with well-known brands like Rheem, A.O. Smith, State, and GE. These companies have a long history of producing reliable products and typically offer better warranties and customer support. Reading user reviews can provide insight into a specific model’s real-world performance and longevity. An established brand is more likely to have readily available replacement parts, like those found in the tune-up kits we reviewed.
Portability/Size - Considerations for space and storage
Always measure the installation space twice. Note the height and diameter of the heater. Tall models are great for closets with a small footprint, while short models can fit in crawl spaces or under stairs. Also, ensure there is adequate clearance around the unit for future maintenance and to meet safety codes. If space is a major constraint, a tankless model might be a better, albeit more expensive, alternative. For other size options, see our reviews of the best 30 gallon electric water heater and best 50 gallon electric water heater.
Is it A Wise Decision to Buy electric water heater 40 gallon?
Investing in a 40-gallon electric water heater is a very wise decision for the majority of American households. This size hits the sweet spot, providing ample hot water for a family of 2 to 4 without the higher purchase price and standby energy costs of a larger 50-gallon unit. Compared to smaller 30-gallon models, a 40-gallon tank offers a much better buffer against running out of hot water during peak usage, a common frustration for families.
While gas water heaters can sometimes have lower operating costs, electric models are generally cheaper to purchase and install, as they don’t require gas lines or complex venting. This makes them a more accessible option for many homeowners. Furthermore, modern electric heaters have excellent insulation and high energy factor ratings, making them far more efficient than older models. The long-term benefits are clear: you get a reliable, consistent supply of hot water to meet your family’s daily needs in a system that is safe, relatively easy to maintain, and efficient. It’s a foundational appliance that significantly contributes to your home’s comfort and functionality. Looking for gas alternatives? Check our best gas hot water heater 40 gallon guide.
What Is the Best Way to Choose electric water heater 40 gallon?
Choosing the perfect 40-gallon electric water heater can be streamlined by following a clear, step-by-step process.
- Assess Your Hot Water Needs: Start by calculating your family’s peak hot water usage. A simple way is to use an online FHR (First Hour Rating) calculator. This will give you a target number to look for when comparing models.
- Measure Your Space: Accurately measure the height and width of the area where the heater will be installed. Don’t forget to account for necessary clearance on all sides for ventilation and maintenance.
- Check Your Electrical Panel: Confirm that you have a dedicated 240V, 30-amp circuit available for a standard electric tank heater. If you are considering a powerful tankless model, you will need significantly more capacity. Consult an electrician if you are unsure.
- Compare Key Specifications: Create a shortlist of models from reputable brands. Compare their UEF (energy factor), FHR (first hour rating), element wattage, and warranty. Prioritize a higher UEF for long-term savings.
- Read User Reviews: Look for reviews from users with households similar to yours. Pay attention to comments about reliability, ease of installation, and customer service experiences.
- Factor in Long-Term Costs: Don’t just look at the purchase price. A slightly more expensive model with a higher efficiency rating and a longer warranty can be a much better value over its 8-12 year lifespan.
Common Mistakes to Avoid:
- Buying Too Small: Underestimating your hot water needs will lead to constant frustration and cold showers.
- Ignoring Dimensions: Nothing is worse than buying a heater only to find it doesn’t fit in the designated space.
- Forgetting Installation Costs: If you’re not comfortable with plumbing and electrical work, factor the cost of professional installation into your budget.
FAQ
What is the best electric water heater 40 gallon for beginners?
For beginners or those seeking simplicity, the Rheem 72-40-2 is an excellent choice. It’s a reliable, no-frills model from a trusted brand that is easy to install and operate. Its straightforward analog thermostat and durable construction mean you can set it up and have dependable hot water for years with minimal fuss. It provides a great balance of performance and value without overwhelming you with complex features.
How much should I spend on electric water heater 40 gallon?
You can expect to spend between $400 and $800 for a quality 40-gallon electric water heater. Models in the $400-$550 range offer solid, reliable performance with good durability. As you move into the $550-$800 range, you’ll find units with higher energy efficiency (UEF) ratings, faster recovery rates, and longer warranties, which can lead to lower operating costs over the life of the heater.
What features are most important in electric water heater 40 gallon?
The three most important features are the First Hour Rating (FHR), the Uniform Energy Factor (UEF), and the quality of the tank lining and anode rod. FHR tells you if it can meet your peak demand, UEF indicates its energy efficiency and long-term running cost, and the tank’s protective features determine its lifespan. A good balance of these three aspects will ensure you get a heater that performs well and lasts long.
How do I maintain my electric water heater 40 gallon?
Regular maintenance is key to longevity. Once a year, you should test the temperature-pressure relief (T&P) valve and drain a few gallons of water from the tank to flush out sediment. Every 2-3 years, you should inspect the anode rod and replace it if it’s heavily corroded. Upgrading to a powered anode rod can eliminate this task entirely.
Are expensive electric water heater 40 gallon worth it?
Often, yes. More expensive models typically have higher UEF ratings, meaning they use less electricity, saving you money every month on your utility bill. They may also feature better insulation, more durable components like stainless steel heating elements, and longer warranties. Over an 8-12 year lifespan, the energy savings can easily offset the higher initial purchase price, making it a worthwhile investment.
What brands make the best electric water heater 40 gallon?
Rheem, A.O. Smith, State, and GE are among the most reputable brands in the industry. They have a long-standing history of producing reliable and durable water heaters. These brands also tend to have strong warranty support and a wide availability of replacement parts, which is important for long-term maintenance and repair.
How long do electric water heater 40 gallon typically last?
A well-maintained 40-gallon electric water heater typically lasts between 8 and 12 years. The actual lifespan depends on factors like water quality (hard water can be tough on tanks), the quality of the unit’s components, and how consistently it is maintained. Regularly flushing the tank and checking the anode rod can help you reach the upper end of that range.
Can I find good electric water heater 40 gallon on a budget?
Absolutely. Models like the Rheem 72-40-2 offer excellent durability and reliable performance at a very budget-friendly price point. While you might forego some of the high-efficiency features of premium models, you can still get a solid, long-lasting water heater from a reputable brand that will meet the needs of a small to medium-sized family without breaking the bank.
Final Verdict
After extensive research and comparison, our top recommendation for the best electric water heater 40 gallon is the Rheem PROE40 T2 RH95 Professional Classic Water Heater. It offers an outstanding combination of high efficiency with a 0.93 UEF rating, powerful performance with dual 4500W elements, and a high first-hour delivery of 55 gallons, making it perfect for families of 2-4.
For those on a tighter budget, the Rheem 72-40-2 Classic remains a fantastic choice, providing proven reliability and durable construction at an unbeatable value.
If you’re seeking to modernize and save space, we highly recommend considering a tankless alternative like the Rheem RTEX-24 Tankless Heater, which delivers endless hot water on demand, provided your home has the necessary electrical setup.
Your next step is to assess your household’s specific needs, measure your available space, and choose the model that best aligns with your budget and performance requirements. Any of these top choices will provide you with years of reliable, comfortable hot water.
- electric water heater 40 gallon
- Reviews products
- amazon reviews
- buying guide
