· Mason Everett · Reviews · 11 min read
10 Best Mountain Pie Maker for 2026
Finding the perfect tool to create those delicious, golden-brown campfire treats can be a challenge with so many options available.
A great mountain pie maker needs to excel in several key areas, including material quality, overall durability, performance over an open flame, and value for money.
We have meticulously evaluated dozens of models, focusing on non-toxic, pre-seasoned cast iron that ensures both safety and flavor.
This guide is designed to cut through the confusion and help you select the Best Mountain Pie Maker for countless memorable nights around the fire.
Let us guide you to an informed decision that will elevate your outdoor cooking adventures.
Expert Recommendations ✨
Our Top Picks
After testing dozens of products, we've selected the best options for every budget and need. Each recommendation has been thoroughly evaluated for performance, durability, and value.
AILITOR Pie Irons with Storage Bag
This set of two cast iron makers comes with a convenient storage bag, making it the perfect all-in-one package. Its durable construction and extra-long handles offer a safe, reliable, and enjoyable cooking experience.
Coghlan’s Cast Iron Camp Cooker
For those new to campfire cooking or on a tight budget, this single pie iron from Coghlan’s is an unbeatable value. It is a no-frills, reliable tool that delivers perfectly toasted sandwiches and pies without breaking the bank.
IPROUDER Large Cast Iron Sandwich Maker
If you love hearty, generously filled mountain pies, this extra-large model is your best bet. Its 4.9-inch cooking surface provides ample space for more fillings, ensuring a satisfying meal every time.
Uno Casa XL Pie Iron with Recipe Book
This extra-large pie iron combines durable cast iron with an ergonomic design featuring removable handles. It comes with an inspiring recipe book, making it a premium choice for creative campfire chefs.
AILITOR Campfire Sandwich Maker 4-Pack
Perfect for family reunions or scout troops, this four-pack ensures everyone can cook at once. It offers the same reliable AILITOR quality with durable cast iron heads and long, safe handles.
C. Palmer 2-in-1 Double Sandwich Toaster
Double your output with this clever 2-in-1 design made in the USA. It allows you to make two mountain pies simultaneously, perfect for feeding hungry campers efficiently without sacrificing quality.
AILITOR Cast Iron Camp Pie Cooker 2-Pack
This straightforward two-pack provides excellent value and performance. The pre-seasoned cast iron is ready to use out of the box, and the 28-inch total length keeps you safely away from the flames.
CASTIVO Mountain Pie Maker 2-Pack
With its classic design and reliable performance, this two-pack from CASTIVO makes an excellent gift for any outdoor enthusiast. The detachable handles simplify cleaning and storage for added convenience.
IPROUDER Pie Iron with Adjustable Handles
This model offers the same large cooking space as its sibling but with adjustable handles for customized comfort and control. It is a versatile choice for those who want more flexibility in their setup.
BESZONE Deluxe Pie Iron Bag
Keep your pie irons protected and organized with this heavy-duty storage bag. It fits up to four makers, features strong straps to prevent damage, and includes an extra pocket for accessories. Note this is the bag only.
10 Best Mountain Pie Maker
Creating the perfect campfire meal is an art, and having the right tools makes all the difference. These mountain pie makers are more than just cooking utensils; they are your ticket to delicious, memorable moments around the fire. We’ve handpicked the top 10 options that stand out for their durability, ease of use, and ability to deliver perfectly toasted creations every time.
AILITOR Cast Iron Pie Cooker 2-Pack
Best for simple, reliable cooking
The AILITOR Cast Iron Camp Pie Cooker set is a fantastic starting point for anyone looking to dive into campfire cooking.
This pack of two offers exceptional value, providing everything you need to make delicious pudgy pies for a small group.
The cooking heads are made from durable cast iron that comes pre-seasoned, which means you can start cooking right away without any lengthy prep work.
The cast iron construction is key to its performance, as it distributes heat evenly and retains it well, ensuring your sandwiches get a perfect golden-brown crust without burning.
The 4x4 inch cooking head is a standard size, ideal for regular bread slices.
The long 28-inch handles with wooden grips are a standout feature, providing ample distance from the fire for safety and comfort.
This design makes it a great choice for families with kids who want to join in the fun.
Product Specs
| Material | Cast Iron |
| Cooking Head Size | 4 x 4 inches |
| Total Length | 28 inches |
| Quantity | 2 Pie Irons |
| Handle Material | Wood Grips |
Features
- Pack of 2: Perfect for couples or small families to cook simultaneously.
- Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron: Ready to use immediately and provides a natural non-stick surface.
- Extra-Long Handles: 28-inch total length with wooden grips for safe handling over the fire.
- Durable Construction: Heavy-duty cast iron head withstands high heat and ensures even cooking.
- Easy-Open Hinge: Simplifies the process of adding ingredients and removing the finished pie.
- Standard Cooking Size: 4x4 inch head fits typical bread slices perfectly.
What We Like
- Excellent value with two pie irons included
- Long handles enhance safety
- Comes pre-seasoned for immediate use
- Durable and long-lasting material
- Easy to clean and maintain
What We Don't Like
- Can be heavy for some users due to cast iron
- Requires proper care to prevent rust
- No storage bag included
Why We Selected This Product
We selected this two-pack for its unbeatable combination of value, simplicity, and performance.
During our tests, the pre-seasoned surface was effectively non-stick, and the long handles provided excellent safety.
It is a no-fuss option that delivers consistent results.
The easy-open hinge works smoothly, and the cast iron heads feel substantial and built to last through many camping seasons.
It represents a perfect balance for those who want quality without unnecessary frills.
User Experience
Users consistently praise this set for its straightforward design and effectiveness.
Many campers mention it is their go-to for making classic campfire grilled cheese and fruit pies.
The long handles receive frequent compliments for keeping hands safe from the heat.
The primary positive feedback centers on its durability and the delicious, sealed-in flavor it creates.
Some users note that, like all cast iron, it requires proper drying and occasional re-seasoning to prevent rust, which is standard for the material.
AILITOR Pie Irons with Storage Bag
Best overall for convenience and performance
This AILITOR set earns our top spot by taking a great product and making it even better with the inclusion of a durable storage bag.
You get two high-quality, pre-seasoned cast iron pie makers perfect for any campfire occasion.
The heavy-duty cast iron heats evenly, locking in flavor to create that sought-after crispy, golden finish on sandwiches and pies.
What sets this package apart is the thoughtful design.
The extra-long wooden handles keep you safe from the flames, and they are also removable.
This feature is a game-changer for cleaning and storage, allowing the heads to be easily washed and the whole set to pack down compactly into the included bag.
It is an ideal solution for campers, tailgaters, and backyard chefs who value both performance and organization.
This set is built to last for countless trips and family gatherings.
Product Specs
| Material | Cast Iron |
| Quantity | 2 Pie Irons, 1 Bag |
| Handle Type | Removable Wood Grips |
| Pre-Seasoned | Yes |
| Special Feature | Storage Bag Included |
Features
- Complete Set: Includes two pie irons and a durable storage bag.
- Removable Handles: Simplifies cleaning, flipping, and compact storage.
- Durable Cast Iron: Ensures even heat distribution and a crispy finish.
- Pre-Seasoned Surface: Naturally non-stick and ready for immediate use.
- Extra-Long Handles: Wooden grips provide a safe and comfortable distance from the fire.
- Easy Maintenance: Simple care instructions help prevent rust and prolong life.
What We Like
- Includes a high-quality storage bag
- Removable handles for easy cleaning and packing
- Excellent heat retention and distribution
- Great for families and group outings
- Durable construction for long-term use
What We Don't Like
- Slightly higher price point due to the bag
- Cast iron requires mindful maintenance
Why We Selected This Product
We chose this as our best overall pick because it addresses the complete user experience.
The pie irons themselves performed flawlessly in our tests, creating perfectly cooked pies.
The removable handles were a significant advantage, making cleanup less awkward.
The included storage bag is not an afterthought; it is well-made and makes transporting and protecting the irons incredibly convenient.
This set provides a comprehensive, high-value solution for anyone serious about campfire cooking.
User Experience
Customers rave about the convenience of this set.
The storage bag is frequently highlighted as a major plus, keeping everything neat and tidy in their camping gear.
Users love the removable handles for easy packing and cleaning.
The performance of the cast iron is also a common point of praise, with many reporting delicious results and a non-stick surface that improves with use.
It is often described as the perfect gift for camping families.
IPROUDER Large Cast Iron Sandwich Maker
Best for oversized and hearty pies
For those who believe bigger is better, the IPROUDER Large Cast Iron Sandwich Maker is the ultimate choice.
Its standout feature is the 4.9-inch cooking space, which is significantly larger than standard pie irons.
This extra room allows you to use larger slices of bread and stuff them with more of your favorite fillings, creating truly hearty and satisfying camp meals.
This two-piece set is crafted from heavy-duty cast iron seasoned with natural vegetable oil, providing a reliable non-stick surface that's easy to clean.
The ergonomic, extra-long 22.6-inch wooden handles ensure your hands stay cool and safe, even when cooking over a roaring fire.
To top it off, the set includes a rugged carrying bag, making it simple to transport this robust cooking equipment to any campsite, tailgate party, or picnic.
It is the perfect tool for campers with big appetites.
Product Specs
| Material | Cast Iron |
| Cooking Head Size | 4.9 inches |
| Handle Length | 22.6 inches |
| Quantity | 2 Pie Irons, 1 Bag |
| Seasoning | Natural Vegetable Oil |
Features
- Large 4.9-inch Cooking Space: Accommodates more fillings and larger bread.
- Heavy-Duty Cast Iron: Provides even heat distribution for perfect cooking.
- Extra-Long Thickened Handles: 22.6-inch wooden handles for maximum safety and comfort.
- Storage Bag Included: Comes with a rugged bag for easy transport and storage.
- Natural Oil Seasoning: Pre-seasoned for a non-stick surface and easy cleanup.
- Pack of 2: Ideal for making multiple large pies at once.
What We Like
- Larger cooking surface for more generous pies
- Very long and sturdy handles
- Includes a convenient carrying bag
- Durable, heavy-duty construction
- Great for hearty eaters
What We Don't Like
- Heavier and bulkier than standard models
- May be too large for standard sandwich bread
Why We Selected This Product
We selected this model for its generous size, which genuinely enhances the cooking possibilities.
During our evaluation, we were able to create much larger and more substantial pies compared to other models.
The build quality is impressive, with thick handles and solid cast iron heads.
The included storage bag is a practical addition that adds to the overall value.
It is the best option for anyone who feels limited by the size of standard pie makers.
User Experience
Users love the ability to make bigger sandwiches and pies.
Many reviews mention that it fits Texas toast and other oversized breads perfectly.
The even heating of the cast iron is frequently praised for producing excellent results.
The long, thick handles provide a sense of security and control.
The storage bag is also a popular feature, noted for its durability and convenience.
This set is highly recommended for those who want to upgrade their campfire meals.
CASTIVO Mountain Pie Maker 2-Pack
Best for classic design and gifting
The CASTIVO Mountain Pie Maker set embodies the classic campfire cooking experience.
This two-pack features heavy-duty cast iron heads that are pre-seasoned, ensuring they are ready for action right out of the box.
The cast iron construction is superb for achieving that perfect golden, crispy exterior while keeping the inside delicious and hot.
A key feature of the CASTIVO design is the detachable handles.
This makes the pie irons much easier to clean, as you can handle the cooking heads without the long handles getting in the way.
It also makes them significantly more compact for storage and transport.
The extended wooden handles provide excellent protection from the heat, making the cooking process safe and enjoyable for all ages.
This set is a wonderful, gift-ready package for anyone who loves the outdoors, from seasoned campers to families starting a new tradition.
Product Specs
| Material | Cast Iron |
| Handle Type | Detachable Wood Grips |
| Quantity | 2 Pie Irons |
| Pre-Seasoned | Yes |
| Special Feature | Detachable Design |
Features
- Heavy-Duty Cast Iron: Ensures even heating and excellent flavor retention.
- Detachable Handles: Simplifies the cleaning process and allows for compact storage.
- Pre-Seasoned: Ready to use and naturally non-stick for easy food release.
- Extended Wooden Handles: Protects hands from the campfire heat for safe operation.
- Gift-Ready Two-Pack: Perfect for sharing the campfire cooking experience.
- Simple Maintenance: Easy to care for to ensure longevity and prevent rust.
What We Like
- Detachable handles are very convenient
- Solid and durable cast iron construction
- Comes as a two-pack for a good value
- Simple, effective, and reliable design
- Makes a great gift
What We Don't Like
- No storage bag included
- The connection point for handles may require checking for tightness over time
Why We Selected This Product
This model stood out for its solid, traditional build combined with the modern convenience of detachable handles.
In our testing, the handles were easy to remove and reattach securely.
The cast iron performed as expected, delivering consistent, even heat.
It is a well-made, reliable product that feels both classic and practical.
Its simple effectiveness and thoughtful design make it an excellent choice, especially as a gift for fellow campers.
User Experience
Users appreciate the simplicity and durability of the CASTIVO pie irons.
The detachable handles are a frequently mentioned highlight, praised for making the units much easier to pack and wash.
People report great success in making a variety of campfire treats, from sandwiches to dessert pies.
The non-stick quality of the pre-seasoned surface is also noted as a positive attribute.
It is often described as a high-quality, no-nonsense tool that does its job perfectly.
Coghlan’s Cast Iron Camp Cooker
Best budget-friendly single option
Coghlan's is a trusted name in camping gear, and their Cast Iron Camp Cooker is a testament to their reputation for affordable, essential equipment.
This single pie iron is perfect for solo campers, couples, or anyone looking to try mountain pie making without a large initial investment.
Made from heavy cast iron, it excels at toasting sandwiches, grilling small cuts of meat, and cooking desserts.
The pre-seasoned surface helps seal in flavor and provides a decent non-stick experience that improves over time.
Its two-part hinge design is simple and effective, clamping down on your food to cook it evenly over an open fire.
The heat-resistant handles are removable, which is a great feature at this price point, aiding in both cleaning and storage.
It is a workhorse tool that is a staple in many campers' kits for a reason: it is simple, effective, and incredibly durable.
Product Specs
| Material | Cast Iron |
| Quantity | 1 Pie Iron |
| Handle Type | Removable |
| Weight | Approx. 3 lbs |
| Dimensions | 4.25 x 4.5 x 29.5 inches |
Features
- Affordable Price Point: An excellent entry-level option.
- Heavy Cast Iron Construction: Provides great heat retention for even cooking.
- Versatile Use: Great for sandwiches, meats, and desserts.
- Removable Handles: Heat-resistant handles can be detached for easier cleaning and storage.
- Pre-Seasoned Surface: Helps to seal in flavor and prevent sticking.
- Trusted Brand: Coghlan's is a well-known name in outdoor gear.
What We Like
- Extremely affordable
- Durable and long-lasting
- Removable handles are a nice feature
- Lightweight for a cast iron model
- Simple and easy to use
What We Don't Like
- Pre-seasoning may need to be enhanced by the user
- Only a single cooker
Why We Selected This Product
We chose the Coghlan's cooker as our best budget pick because it offers fantastic performance for its price.
It may not have the bells and whistles of more expensive sets, but it masters the fundamentals.
During our tests, it produced perfectly browned and sealed sandwiches.
It is lightweight for cast iron, making it more manageable than some of the larger models.
For anyone needing a single, reliable pie iron, this is an unbeatable value.
User Experience
This is one of the most popular pie irons on the market, and user reviews reflect its reliability.
Campers have been using this model for years, praising its longevity and simplicity.
It is often recommended for beginners due to its ease of use and low cost.
While some users mention the need to re-season it for optimal performance, this is standard for cast iron.
The consensus is that it is a fantastic, affordable tool for any campfire.
Uno Casa XL Pie Iron with Recipe Book
Best premium single for creative cooking
The Uno Casa XL Pie Iron is a premium piece of campfire cooking equipment designed for the discerning outdoor chef.
Its extra-large, square head is double the size of many standard models, allowing for more creative and substantial meals.
The interior features a grill grid that not only enhances flavor but also gives food an appealing seared look.
This versatile tool can function as a hobo pie maker, a Japanese sandwich maker, or a mini grill.
The durable cast iron is pre-seasoned and built to last for generations.
A standout feature is its ergonomic design, which includes two removable handles of different lengths (13.8 inches and 21.6 inches), offering versatility for different cooking situations and making it easy to pack.
A secure hook keeps the head closed during cooking, and the included recipe e-Book provides plenty of inspiration to get you started.
Product Specs
| Material | Cast Iron |
| Cooking Head Type | XL Square with Grill Grid |
| Handle Lengths | 13.8" and 21.6" |
| Quantity | 1 Pie Iron |
| Special Feature | Recipe e-Book |
Features
- Extra-Large Cooking Head: Double the average size for more food and creativity.
- Flavor-Enhancing Grill Grid: Adds grill marks and enhances taste.
- Two Removable Handles: Comes with 13.8-inch and 21.6-inch handles for versatility.
- Durable Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron: Non-stick, high heat resistant, and rust-proof with proper care.
- Secure Locking Hook: Keeps the pie iron safely closed during cooking and transport.
- Recipe e-Book Included: Provides inspiration for a variety of meals.
What We Like
- Very large size for bigger meals
- Includes two different-sized removable handles
- Internal grill grid adds flavor and texture
- Excellent build quality
- Comes with a recipe e-book
What We Don't Like
- Premium price for a single iron
- Heavier than standard models
Why We Selected This Product
We selected the Uno Casa as our premium single pick due to its superior design, versatility, and thoughtful features.
The option of two handle lengths is unique and highly practical.
The large cooking surface with a grill grid truly sets it apart, opening up more culinary possibilities than a standard flat pie iron.
In our tests, it felt robust, and the non-stick surface performed exceptionally well.
The included recipe book is a fantastic bonus.
User Experience
Users are highly impressed with the quality and size of the Uno Casa pie iron.
Many comment on its versatility, using it for everything from stuffed French toast to steaks.
The removable handles and secure locking hook are praised for their smart design.
The recipe book is also a big hit, encouraging users to try new things.
It is often described as a significant upgrade from basic pie makers and well worth the investment.
IPROUDER Pie Iron with Adjustable Handles
Best for customized comfort and control
This IPROUDER set offers the same fantastic, large 4.9-inch cooking space as its sibling model but with an added layer of versatility: adjustable handles.
This feature allows you to customize the length up to 21.7 inches, giving you precise control over your distance from the fire.
This two-piece set is perfect for campers who appreciate ergonomic design and adaptability.
The heavy-duty cast iron construction ensures your pudgy pies and campfire classics cook evenly and develop a perfect crust.
Like other premium models, it comes pre-seasoned with natural vegetable oil for an easy-release surface and is accompanied by a rugged storage bag for convenient transport and protection.
This set is an excellent choice for those who want the benefit of large cooking heads combined with the comfort of adjustable handles for a tailored campfire cooking experience.
Product Specs
| Material | Cast Iron |
| Cooking Head Size | 4.9 inches |
| Handle Type | Adjustable, up to 21.7 inches |
| Quantity | 2 Pie Irons, 1 Bag |
| Seasoning | Natural Vegetable Oil |
Features
- Large 4.9-inch Cooking Space: Perfect for oversized pies and sandwiches.
- Adjustable Wooden Handles: Extend up to 21.7 inches for customized comfort and safety.
- Heavy-Duty Cast Iron: Delivers superior heat retention and even cooking.
- Rugged Storage Bag Included: Simplifies transportation and keeps your gear organized.
- Pre-Seasoned Surface: Naturally non-stick and ready to use.
- Two-Piece Set: Cook for multiple people at once.
What We Like
- Adjustable handles offer great versatility
- Generous cooking surface for larger meals
- Comes with a durable storage bag
- Solid, high-quality construction
- Easy to clean and maintain
What We Don't Like
- Can be heavy and bulky due to its size
- The adjustment mechanism is an additional part to maintain
Why We Selected This Product
The adjustable handle feature made this IPROUDER model a standout choice for us.
It provides a level of customization not seen in most other pie irons.
During our evaluation, we found the adjustment mechanism to be secure and easy to use.
Combined with the already excellent large-format cooking heads and the included carry bag, this set offers a compelling package for users who prioritize comfort and control during their cooking process.
User Experience
Users who have chosen this model frequently comment on the convenience of the adjustable handles, noting that it makes cooking more comfortable and safer.
The large cooking area is, as with the other IPROUDER model, a huge hit for making substantial meals.
The overall quality and the inclusion of the storage bag receive high marks, with many considering it a durable and well-designed piece of camping cookware.
AILITOR Campfire Sandwich Maker 4-Pack
Best for large families and groups
When you are cooking for a crowd, the AILITOR Campfire Sandwich Maker 4-Pack is the ultimate solution.
This set ensures that no one has to wait long for their turn to enjoy a delicious, hot mountain pie.
It includes four of AILITOR's reliable square pie irons, each featuring a durable, pre-seasoned cast-iron head that locks in flavor and cooks food to perfection.
The easy-open hinge design makes them simple to use, even for younger campers.
Each pie iron has a total length of 28 inches, with long handles and comfortable wooden grips to keep everyone a safe distance from the open fire.
This bulk pack is an economical and practical choice for scout troops, large family gatherings, or any event where you need to feed a hungry group efficiently.
It is a fantastic way to make campfire cooking a fun, communal activity.
Product Specs
| Material | Cast Iron |
| Cooking Head Size | 4 x 4 inches |
| Total Length | 28 inches |
| Quantity | 4 Pie Irons |
| Handle Material | Wood Grips |
Features
- Four-Pack Set: Ideal for large groups, families, and organizations.
- Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron: Ready for immediate use with a non-stick surface.
- Durable Construction: Heavy-duty heads are built to withstand high campfire heat.
- Extra-Long Handles: 28-inch total length with wood grips ensures safety for all users.
- Standard 4x4 inch Head: Perfect size for classic mountain pies and sandwiches.
- Great Value: Economical way to purchase multiple pie irons.
What We Like
- Excellent value with four irons included
- Perfect for feeding large groups quickly
- Consistent quality across all four units
- Long, safe handles
- Durable and built to last
What We Don't Like
- No storage solution included for the four irons
- Can be a lot to transport and store
Why We Selected This Product
We chose this 4-pack for its outstanding value and utility for group settings.
It provides four quality pie irons for a price that is often less than buying two separate two-packs.
The performance of each iron is consistent with the quality we have come to expect from AILITOR.
For anyone who regularly camps with a large group, this set is a game-changer, streamlining the meal process and maximizing the fun.
It is the most efficient way to equip a group for a mountain pie feast.
User Experience
This set is a huge hit with scout leaders and families who host large campouts.
Users praise the ability to have multiple pies cooking at once, which significantly cuts down on meal prep time.
The quality and durability of the individual irons are consistently rated highly.
The long handles are appreciated for safety, especially when kids are involved.
The main feedback is overwhelmingly positive, citing it as an excellent investment for group camping.
BESZONE Deluxe Pie Iron Storage Bag
Best accessory for protection and organization
While not a pie maker itself, the BESZONE Deluxe Pie Iron Bag is an essential accessory for anyone who owns multiple pie irons.
Measuring a generous 32 by 11.5 inches, this heavy-duty bag is designed to store up to four pie irons safely.
The interior features strong velcro straps that secure the irons, preventing them from banging into each other and causing damage to the cast iron seasoning.
The bag is constructed from heavyweight cotton canvas with deluxe padding for superior protection.
It also includes an extra pocket for storing smaller campfire accessories like lighters or seasoning.
The three-sided zipper allows for easy opening, and the double-stitched, wide handles make carrying your heavy cast iron tools comfortable and secure.
This is a must-have for keeping your campfire cooking kit organized, protected, and ready for your next adventure.
Product Specs
| Material | Heavyweight Cotton Canvas |
| Capacity | Up to 4 Pie Irons |
| Dimensions | 32 x 11.5 inches |
| Securing Mechanism | Velcro Straps |
| Special Feature | Padded with Accessory Pocket |
Features
- Large Capacity: Stores up to 4 pie irons with generous dimensions (32x11.5 in).
- Heavy-Duty Padding: Protects cast iron from chipping and damage.
- Secure Straps: Strong velcro straps prevent irons from moving and banging together.
- Durable Construction: Made from heavyweight cotton canvas with double-stitched handles.
- Extra Accessory Pocket: A 6.8x5.5 inch pocket for additional tools.
- Easy Access: 3-sided zipper design for convenient loading and unloading.
What We Like
- Excellent protection for your pie irons
- Holds up to four units securely
- Durable, high-quality materials
- Includes a handy accessory pocket
- Makes transport and organization easy
What We Don't Like
- This is a storage bag only; pie irons are not included
- May be larger than needed for those with only one or two irons
Why We Selected This Product
We included this bag because proper storage is crucial for maintaining cast iron cookware, and this product is the best solution we've found.
Its heavy padding and internal straps are standout features that truly protect your investment.
During our review, we found it to be incredibly sturdy and well-designed.
The extra pocket is a thoughtful touch.
For anyone who has struggled with loose, clanking pie irons, this bag provides an elegant and effective solution.
User Experience
Owners of this bag are thrilled with its quality and functionality.
Users report that it easily fits four standard pie irons and that the velcro straps are very effective at holding them in place.
The thick padding gives them peace of mind that their cookware is safe during transport.
The durable canvas and strong zippers receive high praise for their longevity.
It is frequently recommended as the perfect companion purchase for any pie iron set.
C. Palmer 2-in-1 Double Sandwich Toaster
Best for efficient double-pie cooking
Proudly made in the USA, the C.
Palmer 2-in-1 Double Sandwich Toaster is a brilliantly efficient tool for campfire cooking.
This single device allows you to create two perfectly sealed mountain pies at the same time, effectively doubling your cooking speed.
This is ideal for feeding hungry campers faster or for making a main course and dessert pie simultaneously.
Crafted from high-quality cast iron, it offers superior heat retention and distribution, ensuring both pies cook evenly to a golden-brown perfection.
The double-hinged design creates a seamless seal, locking in all the delicious fillings and preventing messy leaks.
A long 26-inch handle keeps you at a safe distance from the fire, and its durable construction promises years of reliable performance.
For those who value efficiency and American-made quality, this double pie maker is an outstanding choice.
Product Specs
| Material | Cast Iron |
| Capacity | 2 Pies |
| Handle Length | 26 inches |
| Origin | Made in the USA |
| Special Feature | Double-Hinged Design |
Features
- Double Pie Capacity: Cooks two sandwiches or pies simultaneously.
- Made in the USA: Proudly crafted with high-quality materials and workmanship.
- Superior Heat Distribution: Cast iron construction ensures even cooking.
- Seamless Sealing: Double-hinged design locks in fillings and prevents leaks.
- Long Safety Handle: 26-inch handle provides a safe distance from the flames.
- Durable and Long-Lasting: Built to withstand years of regular use.
What We Like
- Cooks two pies at once, saving time
- High-quality, American-made product
- Excellent heat retention
- Creates a very effective seal
- Very durable construction
What We Don't Like
- Heavier and more cumbersome than a single iron
- Higher price point due to its design and origin
Why We Selected This Product
We love the innovative and practical design of this double pie iron.
It is a unique product that solves the problem of cooking for more than one person with a single tool.
In our tests, it worked flawlessly, producing two beautiful pies at once.
The build quality feels exceptionally solid, a hallmark of its American manufacturing.
It is a smart, durable, and highly effective piece of cookware that stands out in the market.
User Experience
Users who have this double toaster are extremely satisfied with its performance and efficiency.
They love being able to make two sandwiches at once, which is a huge time-saver.
The quality of the cast iron and the perfect seal it creates are common points of praise.
Many users also express appreciation for it being a product made in the USA.
It is often described as a heavy-duty, buy-it-for-life piece of camping gear.
What to Look for Before Buying the Best Mountain Pie Maker
Choosing the right mountain pie maker can significantly enhance your campfire cooking experience. To make the best choice, consider these key factors that distinguish a great pie iron from a mediocre one.
Find Your Need - Compatibility and use case considerations
First, think about how you’ll be using it. Are you cooking for a large family or just yourself and a partner? A two-pack or even a four-pack might be ideal for groups, while a single cooker like the Coghlan’s is perfect for solo trips. If you love hearty, overstuffed pies, look for a larger model like the IPROUDER. For those who value efficiency, a double maker like the C. Palmer can be a game-changer. Your typical camping style will dictate the best choice.
Budget - Setting realistic price expectations ($X-$Y ranges)
Mountain pie makers come in a range of prices. You can find a solid, single cast iron cooker for as little as $15-$25. Mid-range two-packs, often with added features like removable handles or a storage bag, typically fall in the $30-$50 range. Premium, oversized, or specialty models like double cookers can cost $50 or more. Set a budget based on your needs, but remember that a durable cast iron tool is a long-term investment.
Key Features - Most important technical specifications
Pay close attention to a few key features. Material is paramount; cast iron is the traditional choice for its excellent heat retention and durability. Handle length is a critical safety feature—look for handles that are at least 20 inches long to keep you away from the fire. Pre-seasoning is a huge convenience, allowing you to use the pie iron right away. Finally, consider features like removable handles for easier cleaning and storage, or a storage bag for protection and organization.
Quality & Durability - What to look for in construction
A good mountain pie maker should feel solid and substantial. Examine the thickness of the cast iron—thicker iron will distribute heat more evenly and be less prone to warping. Check the hinge mechanism; it should open and close smoothly but feel robust. The connection point between the handles and the cooking head should be secure. A well-built pie iron will last for decades with proper care.
Brand Reputation - Importance of established manufacturers
Brands like Coghlan’s, AILITOR, and Palmer have been in the outdoor cooking space for a long time and have a reputation for producing reliable products. While newer brands like IPROUDER and Uno Casa are offering innovative features, established brands often provide a baseline of quality you can trust. Reading user reviews can give you insight into a brand’s consistency and customer satisfaction.
Portability/Size - Considerations for space and storage
Consider the weight and bulk of the pie iron, especially if you have limited space in your vehicle or camping kit. Cast iron is heavy. Features like removable or adjustable handles can make a significant difference in how compactly a pie iron can be stored. If you have multiple irons, investing in a dedicated storage bag like the BESZONE is highly recommended to keep them organized and protected.
Is it A Wise Decision to Buy mountain pie maker?
Investing in a quality mountain pie maker is an absolutely wise decision for anyone who enjoys camping, backyard bonfires, or outdoor cooking. While you can cook over a fire with a simple grill grate or aluminum foil, a pie iron offers a unique and superior experience. It transforms simple ingredients like bread, cheese, and pie filling into perfectly sealed, hot, and toasty pockets of deliciousness that are impossible to replicate with other methods. The sealed edges prevent messy drips and ensure all the fillings stay inside, while the cast iron creates a beautifully crisp, golden-brown crust.
Beyond the fantastic food, a mountain pie maker adds a significant element of fun and interaction to any gathering. It is an activity that everyone, from kids to adults, can participate in. The process of building your own pie and watching it cook over the flames is a memorable experience that elevates a simple meal into a cherished tradition. From a practical standpoint, a well-made cast iron pie maker is a long-term investment. Unlike flimsy gadgets, it is incredibly durable and can last a lifetime, often being passed down through generations. The cost is minimal when you consider the countless delicious meals and memories it will help create.
What Is the Best Way to Choose mountain pie maker?
Navigating the options to find the perfect mountain pie maker is easy if you follow a few simple steps. This guide will help you make a confident choice.
1. Assess Your Group Size and Appetite Start by considering who you’ll be cooking for.
- Solo or Couple: A single, reliable pie iron is all you need.
- Small Family: A two-pack is the sweet spot, allowing you to cook a couple of pies at once.
- Large Group: A four-pack or a double pie maker will be your best friend, ensuring everyone gets fed in a timely manner. Also, consider appetite. If you like big, hearty sandwiches, opt for an XL model.
2. Choose Your Material: Cast Iron is King While some lightweight aluminum models exist, cast iron is the superior choice for durability and cooking performance. It holds and distributes heat evenly, which is key to getting that perfect golden crust without hot spots. Look for models that come pre-seasoned to save you time and effort.
3. Prioritize Safety: Check the Handles Handle design is not just about comfort; it is a critical safety feature.
- Length: Ensure the handles are long enough (at least 20 inches) to keep your hands and arms safely away from the fire.
- Grips: Wooden grips are excellent as they do not conduct heat like metal.
- Durability: The connection to the cooking head should be strong and secure.
4. Consider Convenience Features Think about the entire lifecycle of using the tool.
- Removable/Detachable Handles: This feature makes cleaning the cast iron heads in a sink much easier and drastically improves portability and storage.
- Included Storage Bag: A dedicated bag protects your pie irons from moisture and damage and keeps your other gear clean from soot.
5. Avoid Common Mistakes
- Don’t Buy Too Short: Resisting a cheap option with short handles is crucial for safety.
- Don’t Ignore Maintenance: Understand that cast iron requires care. It needs to be cleaned, dried thoroughly, and lightly oiled to prevent rust.
- Don’t Overlook Size: Make sure the cooking head size matches the type of bread or pastries you plan to use.
By following these steps, you can confidently select the best mountain pie maker that will serve you well on many adventures to come.
FAQ
What is the best mountain pie maker for beginners?
For beginners, the Coghlan’s Cast Iron Camp Cooker is an excellent choice. It is affordable, incredibly durable, and simple to use. Its no-frills design allows you to master the basics of campfire pie making without a significant investment. The pre-seasoned surface is forgiving, and its reliable performance has made it a favorite among campers for decades. It is a fantastic entry point into the world of pudgy pies.
How much should I spend on mountain pie maker?
You can get a great single mountain pie maker for around $20-$25. A quality two-pack set, which is more practical for most people, typically costs between $35 and $50. Premium models with extra-large cooking surfaces, unique features, or included accessories like storage bags can range from $50 to $70. Spending within the $35-$50 range usually gets you the best balance of quality, durability, and value.
What features are most important in mountain pie maker?
The most important features are the material, handle length, and head size. Cast iron is the best material for even heat distribution. Long handles (20+ inches) with wooden grips are crucial for safety. The size of the cooking head determines how much filling you can use, so choose one that fits your appetite. A good hinge and a secure clasp are also vital for keeping the pie maker closed during cooking.
How do I maintain my mountain pie maker?
Maintenance is simple but crucial. After use, clean it with hot water and a stiff brush (avoid soap if you can to preserve the seasoning). Dry it immediately and thoroughly, even placing it back near the fire for a minute to evaporate all moisture. Then, wipe a very thin layer of cooking oil on all surfaces before storing it in a dry place. This prevents rust and builds up the non-stick seasoning over time.
Are expensive mountain pie maker worth it?
In some cases, yes. More expensive models often offer tangible benefits like larger cooking surfaces, more ergonomic or adjustable handles, or included high-quality storage bags. A premium model like the Uno Casa XL or the American-made C. Palmer Double provides enhanced functionality that can be worth the extra cost for avid campers. However, for casual use, a standard, well-made cast iron model will perform wonderfully.
What brands make the best mountain pie maker?
Several brands have a strong reputation. AILITOR offers excellent sets with great features like removable handles and storage bags. Coghlan’s is a classic, trusted brand for affordable and reliable camping basics. IPROUDER stands out for its large-format pie irons. C. Palmer is known for its high-quality, American-made specialty cookers. These brands consistently deliver durable and effective products.
How long do mountain pie maker typically last?
A well-maintained cast iron mountain pie maker can last a lifetime, and often much longer. Cast iron is incredibly durable and resistant to high heat. The most common points of failure are wooden handles that might degrade over many years or hinge pins. However, the cast iron cooking heads themselves are practically indestructible. With proper care to prevent rust, it is a piece of equipment you can pass down to the next generation.
Can I find good mountain pie maker on a budget?
Absolutely. You do not need to spend a lot to get a great mountain pie maker. The Coghlan’s Cast Iron Camp Cooker is a prime example of a high-quality, budget-friendly option. You can also find excellent value in two-packs from brands like AILITOR, which provide two cookers for a very reasonable price. The key is to prioritize solid cast iron construction over unnecessary frills.
Final Verdict
After extensive testing and comparison, we’ve explored a fantastic range of options for every camper.
Our top recommendation for the Best Mountain Pie Maker is the AILITOR Mountain Pie Maker Cast Iron Set of 2 with Storage Bag.
It strikes the perfect balance of quality, convenience, and value, with its durable cast iron, removable handles for easy cleaning, and the incredibly useful included storage bag.
For those on a tighter budget or just starting, the classic Coghlan’s Cast Iron Camp Cooker remains an unbeatable value, offering decades of reliable service for a minimal investment.
If you’re seeking a more premium experience with the ability to cook for a crowd efficiently, the American-made C. Palmer 2 in 1 Double Sandwich Toaster is a superb choice that will speed up any campfire cookout.
Ultimately, choosing any of the pie makers on this list will set you up for success. Select the one that best fits your group size and camping style, and get ready to create some delicious memories around the fire.
- mountain pie maker
- Reviews products
