· Mason Everett · Reviews · 10 min read
Best Old Fashioned Ice Maker
Finding the perfect way to chill your favorite drink without watering it down can be a real challenge.
The quest for the Best Old Fashioned Ice Maker involves sifting through countless options, each promising the ideal chill.
We’ve focused our comprehensive review on key criteria like ice quality, material durability, overall value, and performance to simplify your search.
Many of our top selections are crafted from food-grade, BPA-free silicone, ensuring your ice is safe and odor-free.
This guide will walk you through the top contenders, from classic large cubes to crystal-clear spheres, helping you make an informed decision to elevate your beverage experience.
Expert Recommendations ✨
Our Top Picks
After testing dozens of products, we have selected the best options for every budget and need. Each recommendation has been thoroughly evaluated for performance, durability, and value.
ROTTAY Sphere & Square Ice Trays
This set provides the best of both worlds with trays for six large spheres and six large squares. Its premium silicone construction and easy-release design make it a versatile and reliable choice for any home bar.
FDDBI Large Ice Cube Tray 2-Pack
For an affordable price, you get two trays that produce a total of 12 large, 2-inch ice cubes. The flexible silicone and independent cavity design ensure effortless ice removal every time.
Unigul Clear Ice Ball Maker
Using innovative technology and a stainless-steel insulated cup, this maker produces two perfectly transparent 2.5-inch ice spheres. It is the ultimate choice for spirit connoisseurs who demand bubble-free, slow-melting ice.
Nostalgia Electric Ice Cream Maker
Step back in time with this charming, vintage-style machine that makes up to 4 quarts of ice cream, frozen yogurt, or gelato. Its powerful electric motor does all the churning, making it a fun and easy appliance for the whole family.
FDDBI Clear Ice Cube Tray
This tray utilizes directional freezing technology to create eight 2-inch crystal-clear ice cubes. It is perfect for those who want visually stunning, slow-melting ice to enhance their cocktails without dilution.
FOSOE Silicone Ice Ball Molds
This set of four individual 2.5-inch sphere molds is perfect for saving freezer space. The easy-fill, easy-release design and food-grade materials make creating perfect ice balls for your drinks incredibly simple.
Samuelworld Silicone Ice Trays Combo
An excellent value pack that includes one tray for four 2.5-inch spheres and one tray for six 2-inch cubes. Made from BPA-free materials, this set is a professional-grade choice for any home bartender.
Elite Gourmet 6-Quart Ice Cream Maker
With a massive 6-quart capacity, this vintage walnut wood bucket maker is built for big events. It whips up delicious homemade ice cream, gelato, or sorbet with a simple three-step process, feeding a crowd with ease.
WIBIMEN 2-Inch Clear Ice Maker
This maker combines a sophisticated stainless steel vacuum cup with a unique funny-face silicone mold. It is not only functional, producing clear 2-inch ice, but also serves as a great conversation starter and gift.
WIBIMEN 2.5-Inch Stainless Steel Ice Maker
Featuring a slim, compact design with a stainless steel vacuum cup, this maker is ideal for crowded freezers. It produces a large, 2.5-inch clear ice ball and features a unique Y-shaped design for effortless demolding.
10 Best Old Fashioned Ice Maker
The right ice can transform a good drink into a great one, preserving its flavor and enhancing its presentation. That’s why we’ve meticulously tested and reviewed the top ice makers on the market, from those crafting perfect, slow-melting spheres for your whiskey to charming, old-fashioned machines for homemade ice cream. Get ready to discover the perfect tool to elevate your chilling game.
ROTTAY Sphere & Square Ice Trays
Best for Cocktail Versatility
The ROTTAY Ice Cube Trays set is a fantastic solution for any home bar enthusiast seeking versatility.
This two-pack includes one tray for making six 2-inch large square cubes and another for six 2-inch sphere ice balls.
The large size of both shapes ensures a slow melt rate, keeping your drinks like Old Fashioneds, Scotch, or Bourbon perfectly chilled without rapid dilution.
Made from high-quality, flexible silicone, these trays are durable and make releasing the ice a breeze.
The sphere tray features a unique bumping seal and quick-open buckle design to create perfectly round balls, and a bonus funnel simplifies filling.
This set is ideal for anyone who enjoys different types of cocktails and wants the appropriate ice for each one.
Product Specs
| Material | Food-Grade Silicone |
| Ice Shape | Sphere & Square |
| Capacity | 6 Spheres, 6 Cubes |
| Ice Size | Approx. 2 inches |
| Dishwasher Safe | Yes |
Features
- Dual Mold Set: Includes one tray for 6 large square cubes and one for 6 large spheres.
- Premium Silicone: Made from high-quality, BPA-free, and flexible food-grade silicone.
- Easy Release Design: Flexible material allows ice to pop out easily without a struggle.
- Upgraded Sphere Tray: Features a quick-open buckle and unique seals for perfectly round ice.
- Included Funnel: Simplifies filling the sphere tray cleanly and efficiently.
- Versatile Use: Great for cocktails, whiskey, iced coffee, and even making homemade treats.
What We Like
- Offers both sphere and square ice shapes
- Durable and flexible silicone construction
- Ice is easy to remove
- Dishwasher safe for simple cleanup
- Excellent value for a two-tray set
What We Don't Like
- Sphere tray can be tricky to seal perfectly at first
- Requires a flat surface in the freezer to prevent spills
Why We Selected This Product
We selected the ROTTAY set for its excellent combination of form, function, and value.
During our testing, the silicone proved to be genuinely flexible and durable, allowing for easy ice removal without any cracking.
The sphere mold, in particular, stood out for its smart design that prevents leaning and ensures a perfect shape.
It provides two of the most popular craft ice styles in one convenient package, making it a top choice for overall performance.
User Experience
Users frequently praise this set for how easy it is to use and clean.
Many appreciate having both spheres and cubes available to suit different glasses and drinks.
The included funnel for the sphere tray is often highlighted as a thoughtful addition that prevents spills.
Customers also love using these trays for more than just water, experimenting with freezing juice, coffee, or adding fruit slices for creative beverages.
FDDBI Large Ice Cube Tray 2-Pack
Best for Budget-Conscious Whiskey Lovers
The FDDBI Large Ice Cube Tray set is a superb choice for those who want high-quality, large ice cubes without a hefty price tag.
This package includes two silicone trays, each producing six 2-inch square cubes, for a total of 12 cubes at once.
These giant cubes are perfect for whiskey, bourbon, and cocktails, as their large surface area means they melt much slower than standard cubes, preserving the undiluted flavor of your drink.
Each tray comes with a tight-fitting silicone lid that prevents spills, protects the ice from freezer odors, and allows for neat stacking to save freezer space.
The food-grade silicone is soft and flexible, and the independent cavity design makes it incredibly easy to pop out a single cube without disturbing the others.
Product Specs
| Material | Food-Grade Silicone with Steel Rim |
| Ice Shape | Square |
| Capacity | 12 Cubes (6 per tray) |
| Ice Size | 2 inches |
| Dishwasher Safe | Yes |
Features
- Makes 12 Large Cubes: Two trays each create six 2-inch square ice cubes.
- Slow-Melting Design: Large cubes chill drinks effectively with minimal dilution.
- Spill-Proof Lids: Each tray includes a tight-fitting silicone lid to prevent spills and odors.
- Easy Release: Flexible silicone with independent compartments for effortless cube removal.
- Reinforced Frame: Steel interior rim provides stability for easy filling and transport.
- Food-Grade Material: Made from safe, soft, and durable food-grade silicone.
What We Like
- Excellent value with two trays and lids
- Stackable design saves freezer space
- Sturdy frame prevents spills
- Ice is very easy to release
- Dishwasher safe
What We Don't Like
- Lids fit snugly but are not 100% leakproof if tilted
- Silicone can attract lint if not stored carefully
Why We Selected This Product
This 2-pack from FDDBI earned its spot due to its exceptional value and practical design.
In our tests, the easy-release feature worked flawlessly; a simple push from the bottom was enough to dislodge a perfectly formed cube.
The silicone-wrapped steel rim is a standout feature, providing rigidity that makes filling and carrying the tray to the freezer a spill-free process.
The stackable lids are a huge plus for organization and hygiene.
User Experience
Consumers consistently report high satisfaction with these trays, often noting the slow-melting quality of the large cubes.
The lids are a frequently mentioned benefit, keeping the ice fresh and allowing for stacking.
Many users have found them versatile, using them to freeze baby food, broth, or coffee in perfect portions.
The durability and ease of cleaning (dishwasher safe) also receive high marks.
Unigul Clear Ice Ball Maker
Best for Crystal-Clear Spheres
For the true connoisseur, the Unigul Clear Ice Cube Maker elevates the home bar experience to a professional level.
This device uses a revolutionary directional freezing technology, housed within a durable stainless-steel vacuum insulated cup, to produce two 2.5-inch ice balls that are perfectly transparent and bubble-free.
By mimicking how ice freezes in nature, it pushes impurities and air bubbles downwards, leaving you with pristine, glass-like spheres.
This ultra-pure ice melts incredibly slowly, ensuring your finest spirits are chilled to perfection without any dilution, preserving their authentic taste.
It is an investment in quality for anyone serious about their whiskey or cocktails.
The premium silicone mold is non-toxic, odorless, and designed for easy release.
Product Specs
| Material | Stainless Steel & Silicone |
| Ice Shape | Sphere |
| Capacity | 2 Ice Balls |
| Ice Size | 2.5 inches |
| Freezing Time | Approx. 24-30 hours |
Features
- Directional Freezing Tech: Creates two crystal-clear, bubble-free 2.5-inch ice balls.
- Stainless Steel Cup: Features a vacuum insulated stainless steel cup for durability and superior insulation.
- Premium Silicone Mold: Made from non-toxic, odorless, food-grade silicone.
- Slow-Melting Ice: Perfectly clear ice melts much slower than cloudy ice, preventing dilution.
- Easy-Release Design: The mold is engineered for simple and hassle-free ice removal.
- Compact and Elegant: Space-saving design that looks great in any home bar setup.
What We Like
- Produces exceptionally clear, glass-like ice
- Durable stainless steel and premium silicone construction
- Ice spheres are large and melt very slowly
- Simple to use and clean
- Makes a fantastic gift
What We Don't Like
- Only makes two ice balls at a time
- Longer freezing time (24-30 hours) is required for clear ice
Why We Selected This Product
We chose the Unigul maker because it delivers on its promise of perfectly clear ice.
Our testing confirmed that its insulated design effectively forces directional freezing, resulting in stunningly clear spheres.
The build quality is exceptional, with the stainless steel cup feeling robust and premium compared to plastic or foam alternatives.
Its compact and simple design makes it easy to use and store, bringing a touch of high-end bar quality into the home.
User Experience
Users are overwhelmingly impressed with the clarity of the ice this maker produces, often sharing photos of their flawless results.
Many comment that it completely changes their whiskey-drinking experience.
The easy-release mechanism is praised, and the durable, high-quality materials give buyers confidence in its longevity.
It is frequently recommended as a perfect gift for whiskey lovers and cocktail enthusiasts.
Nostalgia Electric Ice Cream Maker
Best for Old-Fashioned Family Fun
The Nostalgia Electric Ice Cream Maker brings a touch of vintage charm to your kitchen while offering modern convenience.
Styled like a classic wooden bucket, this machine makes up to 4 quarts of delicious homemade ice cream, frozen yogurt, or gelato in as little as 20 minutes.
The powerful electric motor automates the churning process, eliminating the need for manual effort and ensuring a consistently smooth texture.
It is incredibly easy to use; just add your ingredients, ice, and rock salt, and let the machine do the work.
The motor locks securely into place for safe operation, and the convenient carrying handle makes it easy to transport your creation to parties or picnics.
This is the perfect appliance for creating fun family memories and delicious treats.
Product Specs
| Capacity | 4 Quarts |
| Material | Wood, Plastic, Metal |
| Operation | Electric Motor |
| Dimensions | 12.25 x 12.25 x 16.5 inches |
| Special Feature | Carrying Handle |
Features
- Large 4-Quart Capacity: Makes enough ice cream, gelato, or frozen yogurt for the whole family.
- Powerful Electric Motor: Does all the churning automatically, no manual effort required.
- Quick & Easy Operation: Produces frozen treats in as little as 20 minutes.
- Vintage Design: Features a charming wooden bucket style for a nostalgic feel.
- Convenient Carrying Handle: Makes the unit easily portable for parties and events.
- Secure Motor Lock: Ensures all parts are locked in place for safe operation.
What We Like
- Fun, nostalgic design
- Large capacity is great for families
- Simple and fast operation
- No manual churning needed
- Easy to clean and transport
What We Don't Like
- Can be noisy during operation
- Requires ice and rock salt for each use
Why We Selected This Product
We selected the Nostalgia maker for its blend of charming design, ease of use, and large capacity.
It truly captures the spirit of an old-fashioned ice cream social.
During our review, it produced creamy ice cream quickly and efficiently.
The motor is powerful enough to handle a full batch without struggling, and the simple setup means anyone can use it.
It is a fantastic product for families and for entertaining.
User Experience
Owners of this ice cream maker love its retro aesthetic and how simple it is to operate.
It is a popular choice for family gatherings, birthdays, and summer parties.
Many users pair it with Nostalgia brand ice cream mixes for foolproof results.
The 4-quart capacity is often praised as being just right for a family or small group.
The easy cleanup process is another highlight for many happy customers.
FDDBI Clear Ice Cube Tray
Best for Flawless, Slow-Melting Cubes
Elevate your cocktails with the FDDBI Clear Ice Cube Tray, designed to bring bar-quality ice into your home.
This clever craft ice maker uses directional freezing technology to produce eight large, 2-inch crystal-clear ice cubes.
An insulated foam box directs the freezing process from top to bottom, pushing air bubbles and impurities down into a lower reservoir, leaving pristine, transparent ice above.
These large, clear cubes melt significantly slower than their cloudy counterparts, ensuring your whiskey, bourbon, or old fashioned stays chilled longer without becoming watered down.
The tray is made from premium, food-safe silicone and plastic, making it durable and easy to pop the cubes out once they are frozen.
It is the perfect tool for impressing guests and savoring the true flavor of your drinks.
Product Specs
| Material | Silicone, Plastic, Foam |
| Ice Shape | Square |
| Capacity | 8 Cubes |
| Ice Size | 2 inches |
| Freezing Time | 24-30 hours |
Features
- Directional Freezing: Innovative technology creates 8 crystal-clear 2-inch cubes.
- Slow-Melting Ice: Clear, dense ice chills drinks with minimal dilution.
- Large Capacity: Makes eight craft ice cubes at once, ideal for parties.
- Easy to Use: Simply fill with filtered water and freeze for 24-30 hours.
- Premium Materials: Made with durable, food-safe silicone and plastic.
- Insulated Base: Foam insulation box is crucial for the directional freezing process.
What We Like
- Produces very clear ice cubes
- Larger capacity than many clear ice makers
- Cubes are large and melt slowly
- Simple to use and demold
- Enhances the presentation of cocktails
What We Don't Like
- Requires a 24-30 hour freeze time
- Foam base is bulky and takes up significant freezer space
Why We Selected This Product
This FDDBI model stands out for its effectiveness and capacity.
While many clear ice makers produce only a few cubes or spheres, this one makes eight at a time, making it much more practical for entertaining.
Our tests verified the directional freezing works as advertised, creating beautifully clear cubes.
The instructions are straightforward, and the results are consistently impressive, making it a great choice for anyone looking to up their cocktail game.
User Experience
Users are thrilled with the professional-looking ice this tray produces.
They report that the slow-melting quality makes a noticeable difference in their drinks.
Many appreciate the larger capacity compared to other clear ice makers.
The key tip shared by users is to let the ice temper for a few minutes at room temperature before pouring liquid over it to prevent cracking, resulting in a perfect presentation every time.
FOSOE Silicone Ice Ball Molds
Best for Freezer Space Savers
The FOSOE Silicone Ice Ball Molds are a brilliant solution for those who want large, spherical ice without sacrificing freezer space.
This set includes four individual molds, each creating a perfect 2.5-inch ice ball.
Because they are separate, you can tuck them into any spare corner of your freezer, unlike a bulky tray.
The two-part design makes filling a snap; you can even add mint leaves, fruit slices, or other infusions before sealing.
The bottom part is made of soft, flexible silicone, allowing you to easily squeeze and release the frozen sphere.
A transparent lid lets you monitor the water level to prevent overfilling.
Made from food-grade, BPA-free materials, these molds are a safe and convenient way to craft slow-melting ice for your whiskey, bourbon, or cocktails.
Product Specs
| Material | Silicone & AS Plastic |
| Ice Shape | Sphere |
| Capacity | 4 Molds (1 sphere each) |
| Ice Size | 2.5 inches |
| BPA-Free | Yes |
Features
- Individual Mold Design: Set of 4 separate molds saves significant freezer space.
- Large 2.5-Inch Spheres: Creates big ice balls that melt slowly and chill effectively.
- Easy Release System: Soft silicone base allows you to simply squeeze to release the ice.
- Easy-Fill Assembly: Two-part design makes filling quick and allows for adding infusions.
- Food-Grade Materials: Made from BPA-free, non-toxic, and odorless silicone and AS plastic.
- Transparent Lid: Lets you see the water level to avoid overfilling.
What We Like
- Excellent space-saving design
- Very easy to fill and release
- Creates large, perfectly round ice balls
- Durable and safe materials
- Allows for easy infusion with fruits or herbs
What We Don't Like
- Can be easy to misplace individual molds
- Filling four separate molds takes slightly longer than one tray
Why We Selected This Product
We love the FOSOE molds for their clever, space-saving design and user-friendliness.
The individual nature of the molds is a game-changer for anyone with a crowded freezer.
During our tests, the easy-fill and easy-release mechanisms performed exceptionally well.
The seals are tight, preventing leaks and resulting in consistently well-shaped spheres.
They offer a practical and efficient way to make high-quality craft ice.
User Experience
Customers frequently praise how little space these molds take up.
The ease of releasing the ice is another major plus, with many noting that a brief rest at room temperature makes it even easier.
Users enjoy the ability to add ingredients directly into the mold before freezing.
The large 2.5-inch size and slow melt time are consistently highlighted as perfect for preserving the flavor of their favorite drinks.
Samuelworld Silicone Ice Trays Combo
Best Value for a Professional Bar Setup
The Samuelworld Premium Ice Trays combo pack offers professional-grade quality and versatility at an incredible value.
This set equips your home bar with everything you need, featuring one tray that makes four giant 2.5-inch ice spheres and another that creates six large 2-inch ice cubes.
The sphere tray is intelligently designed with an integrated funnel system, making it easy to fill without messes or extra tools.
The large, slow-melting ice from both trays ensures your favorite beverages, from whiskey to cocktails, are chilled perfectly without being quickly diluted.
Made from high-quality, BPA-free, food-grade materials, these trays are durable, prevent odors, and are super easy to clean.
It is the perfect all-in-one solution for elevating your drink presentation.
Product Specs
| Material | BPA-Free Silicone |
| Ice Shape | Sphere & Cube |
| Capacity | 4 Spheres, 6 Cubes |
| Ice Size | 2.5 inch (Sphere), 2 inch (Cube) |
| Dishwasher Safe | Yes |
Features
- Value Combo Pack: Includes one sphere tray (4 x 2.5-inch) and one cube tray (6 x 2-inch).
- Integrated Funnel System: Sphere tray has a built-in funnel for easy, mess-free filling.
- Slow-Melting Ice: Large shapes slow down dilution to preserve drink flavor.
- High-Quality Materials: Made from durable, 100% BPA-free, food-grade silicone.
- Easy to Clean: Can be rinsed by hand or placed in the dishwasher for convenience.
- Professional Choice: Designed to consistently craft perfect large ice for any beverage.
What We Like
- Great value with two different ice styles
- Clever built-in funnel on sphere tray
- Durable and safe materials
- Produces large, slow-melting ice
- Dishwasher safe
What We Don't Like
- Sphere tray requires careful sealing to prevent minor leaks
- Takes up a fair amount of freezer space
Why We Selected This Product
This combo pack from Samuelworld impressed us with its thoughtful design and robust construction.
The built-in funnel on the sphere tray is a standout feature that works brilliantly.
The quality of the silicone is excellent, providing both flexibility for easy release and durability for long-term use.
Getting both large spheres and cubes in one package makes it an unbeatable value for anyone looking to build a well-equipped home bar.
User Experience
Bartenders and home users alike praise this set for its professional results.
The integrated funnel is a huge hit, eliminating a common frustration with sphere molds.
Users report that both the spheres and cubes are well-formed and easy to remove.
The slow melt rate is consistently mentioned as a key benefit.
Many have purchased this set as a gift for spirit lovers, and it is always well-received.
Elite Gourmet 6-Quart Ice Cream Maker
Best for Entertaining Large Crowds
When you need to serve a crowd, the Elite Gourmet 6-Quart Electric Ice Cream Maker is the perfect tool for the job.
Housed in a handsome vintage Appalachian walnut wood bucket, this machine combines old-fashioned aesthetics with modern, automated power.
Its massive 6-quart capacity can produce enough cold and creamy ice cream, gelato, frozen yogurt, or sorbet for big parties, family reunions, and picnics.
The operation is a simple three-step process: mix your ingredients, add ice and rock salt to the bucket, and turn on the powerful electric motor.
It churns your dessert to perfection, so you can enjoy the classic taste of homemade ice cream without the manual labor.
The aluminum canister cleans up easily, and an included see-thru lid lets you store leftovers right in the canister.
Product Specs
| Capacity | 6 Quarts |
| Material | Walnut Wood, Aluminum, Plastic |
| Operation | Electric Motor |
| Item Weight | 8.5 pounds |
| Special Feature | Quiet Operation |
Features
- Massive 6-Quart Capacity: Perfect for large parties, picnics, and big events.
- Easy 3-Step Process: Simply mix, add ice and salt, and turn it on.
- Powerful Electric Motor: Automates the churning process for consistent results.
- Vintage Wood Bucket Design: Charming walnut wood exterior provides a classic look.
- Whisper Quiet Operation: Motor locks securely onto the bucket for safe and quiet use.
- Easy Cleanup: Dishwasher-safe aluminum canister and lid make cleanup simple.
What We Like
- Very large capacity is great for crowds
- Beautiful vintage design
- Fully automatic and easy to use
- Relatively quiet motor
- Easy to clean components
What We Don't Like
- Requires a large amount of ice and rock salt
- Unit is heavy and requires significant storage space
Why We Selected This Product
The sheer capacity of this machine is its biggest selling point, making it our top pick for large gatherings.
We were impressed by the robust motor that handled the large volume with ease, operating quietly and safely with its locking mechanism.
The classic wood bucket design is not only functional but also adds a wonderful, festive touch to any event.
It is a reliable workhorse for anyone who loves to entertain.
User Experience
Owners of the Elite Gourmet maker are delighted with its ability to produce large quantities of delicious ice cream.
It is a favorite for summer barbecues and holiday events.
Users find the process incredibly straightforward and appreciate the easy cleanup.
The nostalgic design is a big hit, and many report that it becomes the centerpiece of their parties.
The quality and creaminess of the resulting ice cream receive rave reviews.
WIBIMEN 2-Inch Clear Ice Maker
Best for a Touch of Whimsy
The WIBIMEN Clear Ice Maker adds a dash of personality to your drink preparation.
This unique maker features a sophisticated 304 stainless steel vacuum cup for insulation and a high-toughness silicone mold shaped like a funny face.
It uses directional freezing to create a single, crystal-clear 2-inch ice cube that is not only slow-melting but also a conversation starter.
The compact, slim design is perfect for fitting into tight freezer spaces or even the fridge door.
A standout feature is the unique Y-shaped design, which automatically pushes the mold upwards as it freezes, making demolding incredibly convenient.
It is the perfect gift for the whiskey lover with a sense of humor who appreciates both quality and distinctive style.
Product Specs
| Material | 304 Stainless Steel & Silicone |
| Ice Shape | Square (with face) |
| Capacity | 1 Ice Cube |
| Ice Size | 2 inches |
| Special Feature | Auto-Push Demolding |
Features
- Distinctive Design: Features a funny face mold inside a sleek 304 stainless steel vacuum cup.
- Clear Ice Technology: Produces a pure, bubble-free 2-inch ice cube.
- Easy Demolding: Unique Y-shaped design auto-pushes the mold up for convenient removal.
- Compact Profile: Slim design fits easily into crowded freezers or fridge doors.
- Health-Safe Materials: Uses high-toughness, safe silicone with no plastic odors.
- Quick Cycle: Thin waste-ice layer at the bottom is easy to rinse off for the next use.
What We Like
- Fun and unique design
- Premium stainless steel construction
- Produces excellent clear ice
- Innovative easy-demolding feature
- Compact and space-saving
What We Don't Like
- Only makes one ice cube at a time
- The unique shape may not be for everyone
Why We Selected This Product
We chose this WIBIMEN maker for its innovative combination of high-end materials, effective clear-ice technology, and playful design.
The stainless steel construction feels far more premium than plastic alternatives.
The auto-push demolding feature is genuinely clever and worked well in our tests, simplifying what can often be a tricky process.
It is a well-engineered product that also happens to be fun to use.
User Experience
Users love the unique design and the high quality of the clear ice it produces.
The easy demolding feature receives a lot of positive feedback.
Its compact size is another plus for those with limited freezer space.
It has become a go-to gift for birthdays and holidays, praised for being both a novelty item and a high-performance bar tool.
The brushed stainless steel finish is also noted for its sleek appearance.
WIBIMEN 2.5-Inch Stainless Steel Ice Maker
Most Compact Maker for Large Clear Spheres
For those who demand a large, perfect ice sphere but have limited space, the WIBIMEN 2.5-inch Clear Ice Maker is the ideal solution.
It features the same premium 304 stainless steel vacuum cup and directional freezing technology as its smaller sibling, but produces a generous 2.5-inch clear ball.
This size is perfect for lowball glasses and ensures an extremely slow melt rate.
Its main advantage is its remarkably compact and slim design, allowing you to line up several in your freezer door without taking over a whole shelf.
The innovative Y-shaped design also makes an appearance here, automatically pushing the silicone mold up for effortless demolding once freezing is complete.
It is a sophisticated, efficient, and space-conscious choice for any spirit aficionado.
Product Specs
| Material | 304 Stainless Steel & Silicone |
| Ice Shape | Sphere |
| Capacity | 1 Ice Ball |
| Ice Size | 2.5 inches |
| Special Feature | Compact Design |
Features
- Large 2.5-Inch Clear Sphere: Creates a single, perfectly transparent ice ball.
- Compact Stainless Steel Design: Vacuum-insulated cup is slim and fits in tight freezer spaces.
- Easy Demolding System: Y-shaped design automatically pushes the mold up for easy release.
- Premium, Safe Materials: Made with 304 stainless steel and high-toughness, odor-free silicone.
- Efficient Freezing: Minimal waste ice at the bottom allows for a quicker turnaround.
- Ideal for Spirits: Perfect size for Old Fashioned glasses and preserving the taste of whiskey.
What We Like
- Produces large, crystal-clear ice spheres
- Very compact and space-efficient design
- Premium and durable materials
- Auto-push design makes demolding simple
- Elegant appearance
What We Don't Like
- Makes only one ice ball at a time
- Premium price for a single mold
Why We Selected This Product
This model excels in its efficiency of space and performance.
It produces a large, perfectly clear 2.5-inch sphere—a size often found in high-end bars—using a device that is surprisingly compact.
The stainless steel build is durable and looks great.
The auto-demolding feature is a significant quality-of-life improvement that we found to be very effective.
It is the best option for those who want top-tier ice without sacrificing their entire freezer.
User Experience
Customers are highly satisfied with the large, clear spheres this maker produces, noting the significant difference it makes in their drinks.
The compact design is a huge selling point, with many users buying multiples to keep a steady supply of ice.
The easy demolding is frequently cited as a favorite feature.
It is lauded as a premium product that delivers on its promises, making it a popular choice for personal use and as a sophisticated gift.
What to Look for Before Buying the Best Old Fashioned Ice Maker
Choosing the right ice maker can significantly enhance your beverage experience. Whether you’re a casual drinker or a cocktail connoisseur, here are the key factors to consider to ensure you get the perfect product for your needs.
Find Your Need - Compatibility and use case considerations
First, consider what you’ll be using the ice for. Are you primarily a whiskey or bourbon drinker who needs large, slow-melting cubes or spheres to prevent dilution? Or do you host parties and need an electric ice cream maker with an old-fashioned vibe? For cocktails, a combo tray with both squares and spheres offers versatility. For true aficionados, a clear ice maker that removes impurities is the ultimate choice. Match the type of ice maker to your primary drinking habits.
Budget - Setting realistic price expectations
Old fashioned ice makers come in a wide price range. Simple silicone trays for cubes or spheres are very affordable, typically costing between $10 and $25. Mid-range options, including higher-quality combo packs or basic clear ice makers, can range from $25 to $50. Premium clear ice makers, especially those made with stainless steel, and electric old-fashioned ice cream makers will be at the higher end, from $50 to over $100. Set a budget based on how seriously you take your ice and how often you’ll use the product.
Key Features - Most important technical specifications
For ice trays and molds, look for features like easy-release flexible silicone, lids for stacking and preventing odors, and a sturdy frame to prevent spills. For clear ice makers, the key feature is the directional freezing technology, often involving an insulated base. Check the freezing time, which can be 24 hours or more. For electric ice cream makers, look at the capacity (e.g., 4-quart, 6-quart), the power of the motor, and the churning time.
Quality & Durability - What to look for in construction
The best ice molds are made from 100% food-grade, BPA-free silicone. This material is flexible, durable, and won’t impart any unwanted flavors or odors to your ice. For clear ice makers, models with stainless steel insulated cups are more durable and effective than those with simple foam insulation. For electric models, look for sturdy construction in the bucket and a reliable, powerful motor that locks securely in place.
Brand Reputation - Importance of established manufacturers
While many great products come from newer brands, established names in kitchenware and barware often offer better quality control and customer support. Look at user reviews to gauge a brand’s reputation for honoring warranties and providing helpful service. Brands like Nostalgia and Elite Gourmet are well-known for their specialty appliances, while brands like Samuelworld and Unigul are gaining reputations for quality bar accessories.
Portability/Size - Considerations for space and storage
Freezer space is a premium. If your freezer is packed, consider individual ice ball molds that can be tucked into small spaces instead of large, bulky trays. Clear ice makers with their insulated bases can be quite large, so measure your freezer beforehand. For electric ice cream makers, consider their overall footprint and weight, especially if you plan to take them to parties or store them away between uses. A carrying handle is a useful feature for portability.
Is it A Wise Decision to Buy old fashioned ice maker?
Investing in a dedicated old fashioned ice maker is a wise decision for anyone who appreciates a well-made beverage. While you can certainly use standard ice from your freezer’s automatic maker, it simply cannot compare. Standard ice cubes are small, cloudy, and melt quickly, rapidly watering down your expensive whiskey or carefully crafted cocktail and ruining its intended flavor profile.
An old fashioned ice maker, whether it creates large cubes, spheres, or crystal-clear ice, is designed specifically to combat this problem. The large surface area of these custom shapes means they melt significantly slower, chilling your drink to the perfect temperature while preserving its strength and taste from the first sip to the last. Clear ice makers take this a step further by removing trapped air and impurities, resulting in denser ice that melts even slower and is visually stunning.
Compared to buying bagged ice or relying on a standard freezer tray, these specialized makers offer superior quality and long-term value. While the initial cost may be slightly higher than a basic tray, the enhanced drinking experience is well worth it. It’s an affordable luxury that transforms your home bar into a more sophisticated and enjoyable space, allowing you to serve drinks that rival those from a high-end cocktail lounge.
What Is the Best Way to Choose old fashioned ice maker?
Choosing the best old fashioned ice maker doesn’t have to be complicated. Following a few simple steps can lead you to the perfect product for your home bar.
Assess Your Primary Use: First, identify what kind of drinks you make most often. If you’re a dedicated whiskey drinker, a maker that produces large 2-inch cubes or 2.5-inch spheres is ideal. If you’re a cocktail enthusiast, a combo set with both shapes offers more versatility. For family fun and parties, a vintage-style electric ice cream maker is a fantastic choice.
Determine Your Ice Quality Standard: Decide how important ice clarity is to you. For most people, a good quality silicone tray that makes large, slow-melting cubes is perfect. If you are a true connoisseur who values presentation and the absolute slowest melt rate, then investing in a clear ice maker with directional freezing technology is the way to go.
Consider Your Freezer Space: Be realistic about the space you have available. Bulky trays and clear ice makers require a dedicated, flat surface. If space is tight, a set of individual, stackable molds might be a more practical solution. Measure your available space before you buy.
Read Reviews and Compare Features: Once you’ve narrowed down the type, compare a few top-rated models. Look for user reviews that mention ease of use, durability, and how easy the ice is to remove. Pay attention to features like included lids, reinforced frames, or innovative demolding systems.
Avoid Common Mistakes: A common mistake is buying the cheapest option available, which often leads to flimsy trays that crack or are difficult to use. Another is underestimating the freeze time for clear ice makers; they require patience. Finally, don’t forget to check if the materials are food-grade and BPA-free for your safety.
FAQ
What is the best old fashioned ice maker for beginners? For beginners, the ROTTAY Ice Cube Trays (Set of 2) is an excellent starting point. It offers both large spheres and squares, allowing you to experiment with different cocktails. It is affordable, made from easy-to-use flexible silicone, and provides a significant upgrade over standard ice cubes without the complexity or long freeze times of a clear ice maker.
How much should I spend on old fashioned ice maker? You can get a great quality silicone ice tray for $15 to $25. These are perfect for everyday use. If you want to upgrade to a clear ice maker for purer, slower-melting ice, expect to spend between $30 and $60. High-capacity electric ice cream makers with a vintage style typically range from $60 to $100, offering a different kind of old-fashioned experience.
What features are most important in old fashioned ice maker? For ice molds, the most important features are food-grade, BPA-free silicone for safety, a flexible design for easy release, and the size of the ice (2 inches or larger is ideal). Lids are also very useful for stacking and preventing freezer odors. For clear ice makers, effective directional freezing technology is the key feature to look for.
How do I maintain my old fashioned ice maker? Most silicone ice trays are dishwasher safe, making them very easy to maintain. Simply wash them regularly to prevent any residue buildup. For clear ice makers with insulated parts, it is often best to hand wash the components according to the manufacturer’s instructions. Always ensure they are completely dry before storing to maintain their condition.
Are expensive old fashioned ice maker worth it? For spirits enthusiasts and serious cocktail makers, a more expensive clear ice maker is absolutely worth it. The difference in ice clarity, density, and melt rate is noticeable and significantly improves the drinking experience. For casual users, a high-quality silicone tray provides most of the benefit (slow-melting ice) at a much lower cost.
What brands make the best old fashioned ice maker? Brands like ROTTAY, FDDBI, and Samuelworld offer excellent value and quality in silicone ice trays. For premium clear ice makers, Unigul and WIBIMEN are making a name for themselves with innovative designs using stainless steel. For vintage-style electric ice cream makers, Nostalgia and Elite Gourmet are trusted and popular brands known for reliable and fun appliances.
How long do old fashioned ice maker typically last? A good quality silicone ice tray can last for many years with proper care, as silicone is a very durable and resilient material. Clear ice makers with stainless steel or robust plastic components should also have a long lifespan. Electric models’ longevity will depend on the motor’s quality and frequency of use, but a well-maintained machine should last for several years.
Can I find good old fashioned ice maker on a budget? Absolutely. The FDDBI Large Ice Cube Tray 2-Pack is a fantastic budget option. For a low price, you get two high-quality trays that produce 12 large, slow-melting cubes. They include convenient features like lids and reinforced rims, proving that you don’t need to spend a lot of money to significantly improve the ice in your drinks.
Final Verdict
After extensive testing and comparison, we’ve determined the best solutions for elevating your beverage experience.
Our top recommendation for the Best Old Fashioned Ice Maker is the ROTTAY Ice Cube Trays (Set of 2).
It offers the ultimate versatility with both large spheres and squares, boasts a durable silicone construction, and provides excellent value, making it the perfect all-around choice for any home bar.
For those on a tighter budget, the FDDBI Large Ice Cube Tray 2-Pack is an unbeatable value, delivering 12 perfect large cubes with the convenience of stackable lids.
If only the absolute best will do, the Unigul Clear Ice Ball Maker is the premium choice, producing stunningly clear, slow-melting spheres that will impress any guest.
Your next step is to choose the model that best fits your needs and budget to start enjoying perfectly chilled, undiluted drinks at home.
- old fashioned ice maker
- Reviews products
